if taylor played edward and rob played jacob would u think taylor was hotter.

it's not about who plays edward ou jacob, It's about the caracter ( in the book). I like taylor i think he is hot lol..... but i l’amour robert not 'cos he is hotter.
if taylor would have played edward i would still think that he is better than jacob

No it is not about who is hotter. But if it was Robert is, without a dought, the hottest. And I really dont think Taylor'd make a good Edward. Rob looks how Edward is described in the book, hence him getting to play Edward. .

i really dont think so. i have loved robert since he was cedric. : )

I wouldn't like Taylor better, because I like Rob for who he is. It's just a plus that he's Edward.

hell no.To me Robby's the best.I just really like who he is.He is trully a beautiful man inside where it really counts.Plus he is hot.

No. Taylor's cute but Rob is HOT, theres no changing that.

NO :)

no, i dont think so.....

Of course i l’amour Robert Pattinson!!

It's not about who is hotter,it's about the caracter,and rob is the best...

No

No because he's not Rob ;)

No, I don't just find Robert hot because he plays Edward. I thought he was hot before Twilight, when i first say him in Harry Potter!
Taylor's cute but not my type.

taylor lautner wouldnt really make a good edward i think his looks make him seem like the perfect jacob, robert pattinson also makes the perfect edward i think they look like how they are described in the book x but still robert (he wouldnt look right with long black hair and he could not be a werewolf its just not right MDR x

nonononononononooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh way.taylor is not capable to be an edward cullen

probably not but i would still think he was hott like i do now!!! i still think rob is wayyy hottterrrrr!!! LoL

definatly not rob is soooo hot and taylor in my opinion is soooo not as hot as rob!!!!!

it is about who is in the book so i would still take Edward
b.t.w.- rob plays Edward soooooo much better

no he would not

no i think rob would still be cute

No.
I have always been in l’amour with Robert Pattinson, ever since I saw him in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.
So, I would still think that Rob's character was WAY hotter.
-xo.

no way robert is so much cuter. it doesnt matter who he plays the role of.

that just would not look right it takes a man to play Edward not a boy, i dont even think i would walch the movie if that was that case (I think you're the best Rob!!!

No i would not because Robbert is still going to be the best ...to me.

yeh, most likely. not hotter than rob but hotter than he is at the moment.

No, Taylor doesn't appeal to me as a vampire...well actually he doesn't appeal to me as a werewolf. Rob playing Jacob, is interesting. However, Taylor is not "hot" as Jacob.

yes totally!I will always think Taylor is hotter-even if they weren't in the same movie!
good question:-)

Sorry Robert/Edward fans but I am team Jacob all the way and Taylor Lautner plays him perfectly. If Robert Pattinson were to play Jacob it would be messed just like it would be if Taylor played Edward. They both have the perfect roles, but Taylor is much hotter than Robert,Sorry.

I THINK NOT ITS A MATTER OF LOOKS AND CARACTER.

I l’amour them both the same so it would not matter to me.....

ITS NOT ABOUT WHO PLAYS EDWERD ou JACOB IT WANT MACK A BIG DIFFERNS HE WELL STILL BE HOTTER THEN HIM

no, no ...and NO!!

i would probably still l’amour rob...VAMPIRE ou NOT!

Well first I would like to say that if they really did switch roles it would be a CRY AGAINST HUMANITY!!! I am a die hard Jacob fan and believe Taylor has fulfilled the roll of Jacob better then anyone else could and switching with Robert would be an AWFUL idea! Robert has that "quirkeness" about him that allows him to be an excellent Edward. Now if God decided to be mean and they did end up switching rolls then yes I would still think that Taylor would be hotter then Robert if we were basing our answer on looks alone. Taylor has the total package when it comes to portraying Jacob because he has the personality to do it, and could pull off an Edward as well. I think that Robert would be a "So So" Jacob if not less because it just dosen't fit him. That being a dit yes, I do believe that Taylor would STILL be hotter. (Even if he had the same diet as a tick.) :)

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! I think taylor is U-G-L-Y
EW and he wouldnt be able to play edward he isnt good enough...

srry jacob/taylor luvrsss

If Robert played Jacob and Taylor played Edward then I'd think that the movie sucks because c'mon - Rob is not a black haired dark skinned indian boy and Taylor is not a pale (and I've no idea how they would make him pale), tall, messy-haired man.

What ever Taylor plays it makes the chachter so much cuter and better in it i know my Friends i agree with me.

noo!! never

Well i am team Edward all the way but i would stick to my team so sadly Yes :( sorry :(

Not at all!!! but I would still be Team Edward. In this case (if Rob were playing Jacob) I'd l’amour Jacob.

OMG! I never thought of it that way! I think I would still prefer Rob though.

Nice question!may be

huh.. there's a question XD i'm thinking no, and it's most likely no, taylor really isn't my type, but who knows? :P