I absolutely love the song River Flows In You!! It flows much better and it sounds more like something Edward would write. I wish they would change it but I don't think that will ever happen.

don't you think that maybe the lullaby part in the movie is just a portion of it? i was thinking that maybe that's a portion. Because, the cd that Edward gives Bella for her b-day.. well he plays it for her, so we'll prob here it in the movie. so. idk. i know it won't change. I love both songs, but Bella's Lullaby won't change

OMG the river flows in you is soooooooo good. its beautiful. i dont think it will ever change but i wish theyd used yiruma's song in the first place.

I like it the way it is :)

The River Flows In You.... <3
it sounds soo sweet and i can picture Edward playing it.. xxx
I dnt really no exactly what the otha song is.. but my frend has this song on her ipod... named Bella's Lullaby and theres like singing in it.... sooo i dnt no if thats it or not... But if it is then i would deffinetly change it.. lol

Urgh..this was hard! I love them both! But I do agree with everyone who said 'Change it' that River Flows In You sounds more like Edward composed it. But I wouldnt change it because I dont think I would have known about Bella's Lullaby. I think the Lullaby is a portion because I remmebered watching a video on youtube that showed you how to play it and the offical one has the beginning, the part we hear is the ending.

it's not that i don't like the one in the movie (cause i DO), it's just that it ain't very lullaby-ish

i actually love the lullaby.. its very sweet and simple and very pretty

i love both songs but this one is much prettier