I love Steven but I think he is a bit too old to play Jacob Black.

taylor for sure...but if he unfortunately cant play jacob..then steven would be great.

I like Taylor, but he is too young! And, for me, Steven was always the first choice!! :)

OK, at first, I wasn't sure about Taylor, but then, just one little interview completly changed my mind. So now, I've gone from this:
Random Fangirl: Taylor might not be in New Moon!*cries*
Me: Oh dear.

To this:
Random Fangirl: Taylor might not be in New Moon! *cries*
Me:NO! *cries too*

So yes, I do think Taylor should stay on as Jacob in NM. Sorry about the long comment....

At first I thought that ANYONE would be better than Taylor, but now that he's been in twilight we can't go back now... and, to my complete surprise, he was one of the only good actors. He didn't have many lines but his portrayal of Jacob was (and I know I'm over exagerating here) phenomenal. :D

taylor had a couple of lines and was in like 3 scenes of twilight. im sorry but steven doesnt really even look like taylor. he doesnt change that much anywase. so who the hecks gonna pay that much attention to his phisical appearences anyway?! taylor has to play in nm or im not gonna go 2 it. sorry, but now i got the pic of t as jacob, it aint leavin.

Is it final? Jacob is my fave character. That's not fair who cares if he looks to young. He is the perfedt person to play that part. I can't see anyone else to play that part. If anyone knows for sure. plz tell me!!
:(

I love Taylor as Jacob... and if they keep him as Jacob then I'll be super happy.. but if they don't then I will suppot Steven.. if that is who they choose to replace him.

I am not a big fan of Taylor. I have never liked him. I thought he potrayed Jacob nicely,though.But that isn't the real point. It is just that I hate recasts.The cast should not be changed. If they thought that Taylor wasn't buff enough to play Jacob,they should have not casted him in the first place.

i love Taylor!!