la saga Twilight Article: Haven't Read The Book? Then Shut UP!

13

posted by loveyoudarling

Dear Twilight fans,

I was toi one day. Addicted to Twilight and couldnt ever stop lire it even if i had already read it 4 times. But trust me on this one will you. READ ANOTHER BOOOK!!! AFTER toi DO THAT TWILIGHT WILL SEEM LIKE A STUPID ROMANCE STORY.

After I had read Twilight saga about 8 times i read Harry Potter.

And all i can say is whoa!!

1. harry potter has a plot line that has never been used before.
2. twilight was a very easy read. simple sentences. i could write it
3. harry potter uses some imagination.
4. if edward wasnt sexy, everyone would be creeped out par him
5. harry potter>twilight

HARRY POTTER;
The most well thought out livres toi could ever read. There are SEVEN and each one is just as good as the one before. They go together perfectly. J.K. Rowling is a women that has a huge imagination and is tremendously creative. Okay Just Think About It. She wrote Harry Potter without any help. And everythingis made up. Try écriture a story like that. How many copies would toi sell? 100? 1000? Well she sold 11 million copies the first jour the last book came out? Could an average person do that? I dont think so.

TWILIGHT;
Wow. I'm pretty sure it's mostly smitten teenage girls who think Twilight is better. The écriture is low grade, the plot is simple and Bella as the main character doesn't compare to Harry as a main character. She's so flippin supid. And the way it ended, omg, not even a fight. Anyways, toi can't compare four livres about a sappy weak teenager in l’amour with a vampire to a 7 novel masterpiece with growing plots and characters. Harry Potter has so much plus depth. And it appeals to males and females alike.

Ha! Oh yeah Edward was a main charecter in Harry Potter(the movie) haha oh and he dies!!

cindy1212, groovychicklisa and 11 others like this

pixie09 if thats your oppinion ... lol ... ill give you mine :D i read the first harry potter book when it first came out and fell in love with the series and still love it to pieces :D i started reading twilight a few months ago and i completly loved it. it was the first book that i could really get into since harry potter :D i kind of agree that harry potter does have a more thought out plot line and it was really exciting and all that but plz dont bash twilight coz u dont like it as much as another book :D 'to each is their own' hahaha x

odd-duck It's ok that you like Harry Potter more than twilight, that's fine, but not everybody does. Just because twilight uses simpler sentences and whatever else you said doesn't mean it can't be appreciated and if it was written so badly why would it have legions of fans? Both Harry Potter and Twilight deserve their fans. Whether one is better than the other doesn't matter it's what people prefer and enjoy.

EdwardToujours yeah, yeah yeah. the old hp/twilight comparison. we're allowed to love both. two different genres, you're looking at apples and oranges. sometimes a girl just wants a straightforward romance, something you can't get in hp. don't deny us.

ToEkNeE Harry Potter has so much more depth. That line right there says it all.

navajosrock Harry Potter is so boring I mean and Twilight obbsorbs you and Harry Potter is like I cant read this .well thats my point of view

vampiress015 Just a couple of points: 1.This is a TWILIGHT fanspot, not a Harry Potter one. 2. Supid isn't a word- I assume you were trying to spell stupid. And, yeah, every character has their faults otherwise then the reader wouldn't be able to relate to them. 3. It was Robert Pattinson's character Cedric Diggory who died. Not Edward. Robert Pattinson is an actor, not Edward Cullen. Do people just eat one type of food? No. Then surely they're allowed to like AND dislike different books. As I said before, this is a Twilight fanspot, if you're just gonna say horrid things about the book then why bother writing the article at all? What gives you the right to say that Stephanie Meyer doesn't have as much skill as J.K.Rowling? Have you ever published a book?

musiclikelove okay, so you sit here and bash people that are just like you, and you used to be one of the fans of twilight. you love harry potter. big freakin deal. so do millions of other people. duh. you used to like twilight, but then you read another book, and suddenly twilight's just stupid? yeah, that's just great. for you. just because not all of us could sit there and read seven books about a plot line that while original, still has it's cliches. for me, i got to the fifth chapter in harry potter and couldn't read any more. i suppose that you think that i'm some stupid, edward loving, teenage girl? yeah, i'm 15. no, i don't read the books because of edward. i prefer jasper. and alice. there are other reasons that people read twilight than to hear about a sexy vampire. people read the books to escape reality, or because the characters are generally relate-able, or because they enjoy the romance, or because they like something darker. whatever reason the person has for reading it, and liking it, it is their reason. the thing is, you already know everything that i just said. you know why different people read the books. you know everything that happens in the books, you know how easily people fall for these books. however, you choose to act like it makes no sense, when you were exactly the same. making you, a hypocrite.

mwalsh i have read hp b4 i read twilight i have read both series bout 4 times and i will always love twilight i love harry potter but you cant compare the two they are completly different the only two things they have in common are 1. robert pattison was in both 2. they both have great writers stephanie and jk are fantastic my opion they are both bloddy briliant book series and there not comparable

mwalsh i also agree with musiclikelove

mwalsh by the way its cedric diggory that dies NOT edward cullen i thought you liked harry potter if u do y u geting ur characters mixed u sorry if i sounded mean

alice_cullen_12 Twilight has more simple sentences! Really? Well then, can you give me the definition of masochistic, irrovocably, and unconditionally mean on the spot? I'm pretty sure CEDRICK DIGGORY died in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, not EDWARD CULLEN! I like Harry Potter, but I liked Twilight better. Does that mean I'm a "smitten teenage girl?" Maybe, maybe not! That's for me to decide, not you, because I have never met you! (I fervently hope that is true!) By the way, get a dictionary! everythingis: everything is (2 seperate words!) charecter: character (you spelled it wrong!) Why don't you comment anyway? Are you scared you'll be "bullied," because that's NOT what I'm trying to do! I'm trying to explain that you should try to stop putting false reviews about books! It's just hurting everyone. Do you like making people feel bad? It seems like you do, because you certainly made me feel bad! I wish you wouldn't hurt other people's feelings! I agree with EyesOnFire, mostly! (To me Twilight is the best book I've ever read!) So stop being mean, unless you LIKE to hurt people!

jacobblackfan23 TWILIGHT IS SO BETTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Edward000 I totally agree with the most of the comments. I've read both, and I love both, but I don't think you should talk like that! I am maybe just 13 years old, but I can decide by myself if HP is the best for ME or not! Twilight is maybe "simple" as you call it, but that makes it easier to younger fans to read it! I will always think that both Stephenie and J.K. is good writers, but I'm a romantic person, and I felt that Twilight was the book I had been waiting for. So don't.. please don't speak that ugly about Stephenie and her books. I'm sure Stephenie would be sad about what you said, and if you hurt her, then you hurt me, and everyone else that loves her books as mutch as I do..

iloveejasper harry potter all the way! twilight sucks! Here Are Some Points Why... - If it wasn't for edward no one would like it - poorly written - the story line is so stupid - and bella should get a life! GO HARRY POTTER

TeamPotter1960 um.. I like Harry Potter better. SRRY! There's just something about Bella's point of view that pisses me off! IDK! I've read the books and midnight sun for some reason I like Midnight Sun but not Twilight idk? as for the dp it says TWILIGHT not Midnight Sun! Idk! oh and plz dont insult J.K. Rowling to meas I burst k? Warning! Lol. I don;t mind if you don't like HP DOn't insult it though. Cuz that's what we're doing! Twilight fan says something stupid HP fan Leaps. HP fan says something stupid Twilight fan leaps! First one to make peace gets cake!

7jacobblack77 I read harry potter since like i was really small up to now. the plot for harry potter i hav never seen in any other book. it is like every sentence holds some important significant. the harry potter world is by far larger than the twilight world. i read the twilight series alot of times 2. twilight is more romantic.............its almost every girl's dream to b in the twilight book.......it is more romantic. even i would want 2 hav a vampire hot boyfriend........or jacob.i want jacob. stephenie is so awesome and so is jk rowling. but harry potter has violence and such a genious storyline.words cannot describe it. The world of harry potter is much more than that........so intricately made. No one should diss any of the authors. Because the romance in twilight is something real........not the characters........har storyline is awesome 2.......and no one should diss stephenie meyer. JK Rowling spent like 5 YEARS PLANNING HARRY POTTER. I know that she is one of the best authors ever.....and just because robert pattinson acted as cedric who had to die it has nothing to do with any of the books.....edward and cedric are 2 different people. And the twilight series does NOT HAVE A BORING STORYLINE. NOR IS IT STUPID. TRY TO PICTURE URSELF IN BELLA'S PLACE........ALL THE PEOPLE WHO SAID SHE THINKS STUPID. Both books helped me love things!!!!!!!!!!!

7jacobblack77 Also both series teaches young and old readers about teachings and feelings that they should know about

7jacobblack77 I also agree with EyesOnFire ........sort of

iluvhp I like Harry Potter and Twilight the same and there totally different by genres not stupidness.

cmangel777 navajosrock - Its because you are obsessed with Twlight that you can't spell ABSORBED right. I respect Stephanie Meyer and Twilight since I will say i've read every book, and they are...ok. If you want an easy book to make you feel all good and warm inside. But the general theme in the book is Bella complaining about how her life sucks, she wants to die because Edward is gone and that she loves Edward and wants to be a vampire even though she fell in love with him after hardly knowing him.

cindy1212 she does has a point.in twilight you no that she is gonna pick edward anyway so what's the point and in harry potter books when u read them it's so cool how u can actully picture what's going on :P

SEEKER6 OMGG thank you thank you for writing this! You r sooooooooooooooo right. And she's not bashing on twilight.