who thinks that they picked the wrong person to play edward? and if soo who do u think should of been edward?

I think Robert is brilliant! He is very "Edward Cullen" ! :) He seems very talented in both jouer la comédie & music, n obviously, he's gorgeous!! :)

I think maybe Heath ledger when he was younger ou a young Johnny Depp

i think they made a good choice with robert because he was virtually unknown.
if they didn't choose him though, i don't know..

maybe conor oberst if he was an actor...
he's pale, has reddish brown hair, and is a musician.

No they picked the perfect person to play edward even when people say that they are twilight fans when there really only like twilight becouse of the guys.

i think rob has a really big head -- he has the features of Edward, I must agree, but i don't find him attractive. he has that whole "vampire" look going on. i would have picked someone else, maybe gaspard ( who played hannibal ) but, i personally think rob is a good edward, even though i despise him.

they ABSOLUTELY pick the right person ..
he gets that vampire look ..

robert is the best!!

I think Robert is ok for Edward, he acts good, and, of course now nobody could take his place)))
But also it seems interesting to see how Gaspard Ulliel would play Edward, i guess that he could be better for this role))He is really good actor))

they chose the right person nobody could of did it better.

Finally,I don't know if it is the right choice!All we see him play the role of Edward,for many time,so we are really used to him,and noene else could replace him in our minds...Right?

becuz ima jacob fan of course im gonna say jacob! but i gotta be honest edward was the right guy to play tht part..

p.s. i also the makeup wouldve made jacob HELLA UGLY! : p

Personally, I don't really think we'll ever know the answer to that question. There are so many unique and talented actors out there that won't be able to grace our screens because they aren't donné the chance. So, from that perspective, maybe there are actors out there who would have suited the role much better than Robert did.

However, I think that Robert did a splendid job of playing Edward- he truly a volé, étole the montrer away. Thus, I think he was great enough.

i think they picked the wrong person but i dont know of anyone else

What ?? Rob Is Perfect For edward Role :)