salut does anyone here get really annoyed when people who have not read the livres judge twilight from the films???

Well, it basically two diffirent things. In my opinion; livres good, movie bad. So I judge the movie, because they can't act. Simple.


Apart from carlise, he can act.

Yes, it annoys me.They think they know everything about it just because they watched the movie.Don't get me wrong, I l’amour the movies.But the livres are plus detailed and better.I also don't think it's fair how someone judges the actors and actrices in it over that certain role.

Saying that they can't act.If they couldn't act, then they wouldn't have gotten the part in the first place.

Being honest, if those people who do not read the books, won't really understand what's going on with the movie. In books, toi know the expression/thoughts/feeling of the character but in the movie, they can't do that so that is why people judge the book par it's cover.

Example:
In eclipse, the part where Bella Kiss Jacob. Alot of my Friends thought that Bella is selfish. Already have Edward but still want Jacob. However, if those people who read the books, we know why Bella actually did that.

So, i'm 100% agree with you!!

I l’amour THE FILMS,BUT toi DON'T KNOW ALL ABOUT THE SAGA FROM WATCHING THE FILM BECAUSE THEY LEAVE A LOT OF GOOD POINTS OUT.THE GOOD THING ABOUT THE livres ARE THAT THEY TELL THE STORY FROM A LOT OF DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES THAT THEY DON'T montrer IN THEATERS ou ON DVD ou ON BLU-RAY SO YES I DO GET EXTREMELY GET FRUSTRATED FROM PEOPLE THAT JUDGE IT WHEN THEY DON'T KNOW WHAT'S ABOUT.

Yes I do because the livres explain things the movie doesn't....so they should watch the films AND read the livres before judging The Twilight Saga.

yes i mean really if they read the livres they would hate themselves for making fun of it!! its soo annoying!