It doesn't matter if someone loves it ou not. All that matters if that toi like it. I've had plenty icones that wasn't populaire with others and alot that was. BUT nonetheless I liked that icone and I put it there for me. Don't depend on other to like your icon. I'm pretty sure there's tons of icones in my gallery that toi wouldn't like.
As for the question: I like it but I didn't mind the other one. I'm just not a fan of the Jonas Brothers.