répondre à cette question

Edward vs Harry Question

1000 Reasons Harry Potter is better than Edward Cullen

Come on Potter-heads,let's montrer 'em what we got.
 1000 Reasons Harry Potter is better than Edward Cullen
*
PLEASE NUMBER THE REASONS!!!!!! THANKYOU!!!!!
lemony44 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Wow lol, another " 1000 reasons " thing. This would be easier in a forum.
RavenclawPride posted il y a plus d’un an
*
It's not Edward in the pic, it's Cedric! Cedric rocks, Edward sucks XD lol. Well, my opinion.
Aquamarina posted il y a plus d’un an
 lemony44 posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Edward vs Harry Réponses

DracoLuver said:
108. (This may have been listed before)

Harry is plus herioc. In New Moon and Breaking Dawn, Edward didn't care about anyone else but Bella. He didn't care if children were going to die. He didn't care if those innocent people would NEVER return to their families. He didn't care about Bree and how she wanted to change. How she was attempting to do something difficult. In BD he gave the vampires cars to lend to go hunt. Did he care about people the people he was endandering? NO! Let's look at Harry

Book 1: He firmly told Hermione and Ron not to go with them because he wasn't sure about the danger they might face. He also, knowing they would get in trouble, helped Hagrid hide his dragon.
Book 2: At the age of 12 he went into the Chamber of Secrets which was rumoured to be housing a dangerous creature just to save Ginny.
Book 3: He saved Buckbeak and Sirius and also saved his godfather from plus then 100 dementors relying on his faith.
Book 4: He took a golden egg from a dragon, he saved Ron and Gabrielle and almost killed himself because of his lack of air, and also fought of Voldemort after being in severe emotional and physical pain.
Book 5: Although he was angsty, he had to suffer punishment (cutting into his own hand and écriture with his blood), making a group (along with Hermione) to teach the students how to properly defend), going to the Ministry of Magic and surviving brains, shards of glass, a veil that may cause death, and spells thrown from every direction. He also saw his godfather die in front of him, and still managed to fight Voldemort from possesing him.
Book 6: He saved himself from Draco killing him, and he saw his mentor shriek in pain as he tried to fight off dead bodies (inferi). He saw him DIE in front of him because of a man he hated, knowing that now he had Lost his only hope.


I'm going to skip Book 7 because I know I have left out MANY of his other accomplishments, and also, Book 7 has so many more! Okay, now Eddykins

Book 1: Fought of James along with six of his family members. Seven against one, pretty heroic, eh?
Book 2: Almost commited suicide.
Book 3: Saved Bella from Victoria, but that took no time at all and he suffered no casualties.
Book 4: Got protected par Bella.

Now, who seems plus Rebelle and loyal? I don't know about anyone else, but Harry seems like a better person who would protect me more. That is why he is better. I may post some plus reasons, but I'm done for today. Oh, and lots of people think Eddy is hotter. Robert Pattison looks like he dumped flour on himself, has horrible teeth, busy eye-brows, and disgusting hair. Daniel has a cute accent, and really pretty eyes. :)
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Amen to that!
MyronPwnsBella posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Agree with everything, especially the eyes!
Angel-Trix posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Yes, but anyone could've gone in. He went in specifically to save Ginny :) .. I don't even think he knew Voldy was the problem. He only found out after
DracoLuver posted il y a plus d’un an
Bellatrix-Black said:
51. He doesn't even THINK about eating people XD
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
littlelemon said:
Why is everyone so against Edward? He's the best, he's ultra cool and well sexy!
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
"He's the best, he's ultra cool and well sexy!" Well, that are three (quite weak) arguments while we're at number 60 now. And I think that Harry is the best, ultra cool and well sexy too; even plus than Edward in my opinion. So your statements don't work, sorry. Try again.
Aquamarina posted il y a plus d’un an
*
finally! someone understands.
littlelemon posted il y a plus d’un an
*
thqankyou, applause for littlelemon and kittyluvaxoxo, im fed up with fighting with these hp luvas, it's just a waste of time not to mention tiring!
zoohi posted il y a plus d’un an
DiNozzosShorty said:
i tink dis pic explains my reason very well ur welcome
select as best answer
 i tink dis pic explains my reason very well ur welcome
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Yes! PLEASE NUMBER THE REASONS!!!!!!! THANKYOU FOR POSTING ONE!!!!!!
lemony44 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Sweet.
ravenclawgirl5 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Harry rocks:DDDD its right
Arianaaaaaa posted il y a plus d’un an
RandomTemporary said:
2. He can be related to.
3. Not perfect.
4. Actually funny.
5. Not a stalker.
6. Not abusive.
7.The fact that he sacrifised himself to save the wizarding world.
8. He's not JK Rowling's dream husband.
9. He gets a joke.
10. He laughs.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
It's actually me Lemony44!!!
RandomTemporary posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Well hello.
RavenclawPride posted il y a plus d’un an
*
*Note sarcasm when I a dit "money is important to a character"
QuibblerQuoter posted il y a plus d’un an
bri-marie said:
11. He's brave.
12. He's loyal.
13. He doesn't put Ginny in danger.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
good ones! kEEP IT UP!
lemony44 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
thank toi :)
bri-marie posted il y a plus d’un an
*
seriously ?! he walked, facing his destiny, he sacrificed himself for the whole world can be free from Voldemort and Death Eater. like really ??
rheiicullen_78 posted il y a plus d’un an
harrypotterbest said:
14. He actually has a brain
15. he has a cœur, coeur of gold
16. people like him becouse of his personality
17. he can make people laugh
18. he's kind and thoughtfull
19. he doesn't always think of himself, like eddy, he thinks of others
20. he makes mistakes like everyone else
21. Potter has been through more
22. his appearance is plus normal and every-day like
23. he doesn't give up ou leave
24. he gets out of tight situations using his brains and not his looks
25. he sometimes loses his temper - like us
26. he's plus well known than eddy
27. he doesn't SPARKLE
28. he's not perfect, so he's easier to relate too
29. he gets cut up and bruised too - like everyone normal does
30. his auteur did NOT dream him up
31. he found his perfect pair AFTER breaking up with someone
32. he goes through hardships like we do
33. he's not always popular
34. he didn't just BECOME popular, he had to work for it
35. he gets school work and actually does it to get good marks
EDIT:
Making mistakes, getting hurt, and losing his temper makes it easier for us to relate to him. Every single human on Earth has gotten hurt at least once, I am sure of it.

select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
24. He doesnt sparkle.
RandomTemporary posted il y a plus d’un an
*
doesnt SPARKLE XD good one! :D
Snowiyflake posted il y a plus d’un an
*
s'alrigh'
harrypotterbest posted il y a plus d’un an
happyallie said:
SAME THING I a dit ON HP VS. TWILIGHT:

36.HE DOESN'T HAVE TO BE SHIRTLESS ou SPARKLE TO BE INCREDIBLY AWESOME

37.UM...HE'S A WIZARD,THAT ADDS A LOT OF AWESOMENESS COMPARED TO A WIMPY VAMPIRE.

38.HARRY PLAYS QUIDDITCH, NOT BASEBALL *BOO!!*

39.HE CAN BE ABNORMAL AND STILL HAVE Friends THAT AREN'T "RELATED" TO HIM.

40.YOU CAN HERE HIM WHEN HE TALKS IN MOVIES.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
WIN on reason 39. sooo true
lemony44 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
to potter forever : it is valid and what have u a dit which is plus valid than my reasons?
zoohi posted il y a plus d’un an
*
to happyallie: if u think edward is not dazzaling, well thats your opinion, and edward didn't kill himself when bella was weak and pregnant because he knew that would cause her pain and it would make her weaker so he decided to bare the pain of bella in well pain and was commited and a dit if bella died he woul kill himself (a very sellfless move) just so he could b with bella, he was giving up his own life just for her. if u watch other films of robert Patterson u will see that he is a great actor and thats not his voice but in twilight he puts that voice on cause he is trying to express his character through hhis jouer la comédie skills . it tells us how much he has been through and how much edward has sacraficed and how much loss and pain he has witnessed.
zoohi posted il y a plus d’un an
PotterForever said:
41. He has a personality

42. fans like him because he is a great character, not because they want to get in his pants.

43. He dosent abuse his girlfriends

44. He is immensley loyal

45. He isn't a pedophile

46. He dosent watch Ginny when she sleeps

47. He has been through some of the most difficult experiences imaginable, yet came through it and was still willing to sacrafice himself for the people around him.

48. His looks aren't described every page

49. He is a sympethetic character.

50. The livres he stars in are actually good.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
i l’amour reason 46
happyallie posted il y a plus d’un an
*
same that would be creepy if he watched her sleep and if ron found out uh-oh!
buckingbronco posted il y a plus d’un an
*
MDR 42
snusnu13 posted il y a plus d’un an
ravenclawgirl5 said:
52. He saved the entire wizarding world and pretty much the muggle world, too.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
LordVInDaHOOD said:
52. Harry doesn't have to resist the urge to eat Ginny whenever he angs out with her.

53. When was the last time EDWARD saved the world from a powerful evil dude??

54. Harry doesn't have fangs

55. Ginny actually has a personality. Bella just goes around moping and talking about how in l’amour with Edward she is

56. Harry doesn't glitter

57. Can Edward ride a broomstick? No.

58. No one ever has to worry that Harry will throw them through a mur ou suck their blood.

59. Edward doesnt have a cool scar

60. Harry has a better villain, I mean, Voldemort would totally kick the Volturi's butts.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
emilykuru said:
60.harry does not kill himself.

61. he does not l’amour ginny because she SMELLS GREAT.

62. harry does not spend his time struggling not to kill his girlfriend.

63.he's way plus mature.

64.he is so courageous.

65.he has faced plus troubles in life than edward who only faced pain once.

66.he will give his life for good cause and edward wouldnt becoz he has to go accueil to bella.

67.he fights villains originally and not dramatically.

68.he faces plus dangerous fighters who wont run off like the volturi.

69.harry is COOL enough to stand up against teachers(he rockz) but edward is (uh)

70.he's not a way too boring 'perfect in all' guy.

71.he breaks rules.

72.he can handle his feelings.

73.HE HAS TRUE FRIENDS.

74.even though lily died, harry had molly, will edward have someone other than esme?

75.he does not scare girls off(jessica)

76.he's not wierd.

77.people l’amour lire about him.

78.people live with his character.

79.he was the BOY WHO LIVED.

80.harry can take down any vampire - maybe not becoz vamps RUN OFF before the showdown.

81.his l’amour was plus original.

82.he was not whiny like edward.

83.he gave up the deathly hallows - wand,stone.

84.he is a true friend

85.there are people who die for him.

86.he won the TRIWIZARD TOURNAMENT.

87.he has the SCAR.

88.ginny does not trouble him par telling i want to go with..(bella-jake-edward)

89.his children are far cuter.

90.he helps even people who wish him ill(crabbe,goyle)

91.he ran off to help sirius - edward wouldnt budge from bella.

92.he wont leave ginny.

93.he is mortal - like us and being normal he's an hero!

94.he has hermione for a sister and she is far better than alice.

95.his parents sacrificed their life for him.

96.he is invincible( volde couldnt defeat him)

97.people gave their lives for him.

98.he is soooo SELFLESS.

99.he is obedient -to dumbledore even though ron and hermione were a bit angry.

100.he TRUSTS HIS FRIENDS!

there u go. for now its hundred.next time i'll add plus to it. HARRY IS THE BEST.

potter fans are plus sincere and dedicated than twilight. if someone goes and asks help in the twilight club for help against hp fans they tell them they dont bother - we wont!

select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
Angel-Trix said:
Yay, we're up to 100!

101. "...the difference between being dragged into the arena to face a battle to the death and walking into the arena with your head held high. Some people, perhaps, would say that there was little to choose between the two ways, but Dumbledore knew — and so do I, thought Harry, with a rush of fierce pride, and so did my parents — that there was all the difference in the world."
Those two sentences from Harry were just so...They just let toi know how much Harry has had to face and how much he was still going to face. The lines gave so much meaning, plus than Edward could ever ahieve.

Please, "The lion fell in l’amour with the lamb"? He's over a hundred years old and what has Edward ever done tosave the world. Harry was willing to save his friends, and enemies. And he was just 16 when he realised this.

102. Harry's temper. His temper shows us that Harry is human. He gets angry. Hell, he nearly completely trashed Dumbledore's office (I was crying in that chapter). Edward however, is so...Perfect. He has to be so smart, and handsome, and gets everything he wants. Harry isn't perfect. Those little flaws are things we all love. We adore his fits of rage over his loss and tiny moments of initial stupidity.

We know that there's a guy out there, who probably is nearly like him. Hot tempered and funny, and toi know that just someone who is as kind and selfless as Harry, with his flaws is out there, and you...Dream.

Edward is perfect. He isn't real. He's a sculpture. I read about him and thought "He's frozen. I can't grow old with someone like this. I need someone with flaws and learn to l’amour them, because this boy does not exist. And I don't want anyone like him."

Hard to explain, but if you're a Potter fan, I think you'll get it.

103. Harry never called Ginny a "Silly girl".

104. Edward wouldn't let Bella see Jacob because he was a werewolf and was potentially dangerous. Thats rich coming from the vampire who lusts for her l’amour but has amazingly perfect self control (Sarcasm right here. And did toi notice the 'perfection' again?).

105. After he left Bella, he left her in the middle of a forest. Way to break her cœur, coeur even more, toi moron.

106. When Harry's fighting, he isn't described as looking like he's dancing.

107. Harry has a heartbeat. And he's warm. Don't toi just want to cuddle up in front of the feu in an fauteuil with him? His skin is also soft, and his breath is warm. Why's? because he's alive.

Edward is dead, cold and hard. I don't want a dead guy following me to my house and climbing into my room watching me sleep. HEY! THAT COULD BE A PLOT FOR A HORROR FILM!
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
So come on littlelemon! Give me your best shot! I'm ready to have a good debate. Oh, and I'll add plus later! I'm just REALLY tired at the moment. XD
Angel-Trix posted il y a plus d’un an
*
good one!
emilykuru posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Ohmygosh - MAKE TTHAT HORROR MOVIE! Let's see if Stephenie realizes that it's from Twilight. :p Great reasons!
DracoLuver posted il y a plus d’un an
Herm-o-ninny said:
109. Harry's child doesn't fall in l’amour with his ex/best friend/ etc. The whole Renesmee and Jacob thing would be equal to Snape falling in l’amour with Harry (Lily would be Bella, Snape would be Jacob and James would be Edward) ou Albus falling in l’amour with Cho Chang (Harry would be Bella, Ginny would be Edward and Cho would be Jacob).
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Albus Severus Potter, right? Because that could be horribly misconstrued. xD
Quaila posted il y a plus d’un an
PotterLucy said:
110 - Harry didn't want Ginny to make an abortion as Edward wanted Bella to do
111 - Harry is not weird and selfish as Edward
112 - Harry is so good that the Weasleys loved him and had no trouble with his relationship with Ginny. Charlie hated Edward.
113 - Harry has much plus courage than Edward, because he fights his enemies and, as he is a human, he can die, but fights anyway, because it's the right thing to do.
114 - Harry doesn't manipulate people. Edward does that a lot.
115 - Harry is a good father. Edward don't.
116 - Harry was capable of leaving Ginny not to put her in danger. Edward is always subjecting Bella to danger - even when he leaves.
117 - Harry doesn't fight his feelings like Edward.
118 - Harry was never mean to Ginny. Edward treat Bella bad when they first met.
119 - Harry does what he says. Edward is too coward for that.
120 - Harry fought Voldemort instead of running because it was the right thing to do. He didn't think about himself. He wanted to protect everyone. Edward protects Bella because he loves her.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
zoohi said:
Edward is the best FULL STOP if anyone thinks otherwise they can go eat slug intestines... NOT JOKIN THERE >:(
select as best answer
 Edward is the best FULL STOP if anyone thinks otherwise they can go eat slug intestines... NOT JOKIN THERE >:(
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
if toi think edward is the best then give us your reason. i personally think that Harry James Potter is the best. thank toi :)
ReibyKathBlack posted il y a plus d’un an
*
thats what i call true love,something that harry doesnt posess, he hasnt got a heart!! and for your information edward could get harrys want before he even cast the spell thanx to edwards super speed so there stuff that in your face!
zoohi posted il y a plus d’un an
*
*wand
zoohi posted il y a plus d’un an
danfan1 said:
Harry is....
1.Smart
2.kind
3.funny
4.brave
5.loyal
6.good leader
7.friendly
8.cute
9.has lots of Friends
10.he dosen't need to go to the voltori
11.he has sirius black and the rest of the order of the phoenix
12.he has got the weasley family
13.he is not adopted and edward is
14.he doesnt sparkle in the sunshine
15.he has friends
16.HARRY IS THE BEST!!
17.he has l’amour all a round him.
select as best answer
 Harry is.... 1.Smart 2.kind 3.funny 4.brave 5.loyal 6.good leader 7.friendly 8.cute 9.has lots of Friends 10.he dosen't need to go to the voltori 11.he has sirius black and the rest of the order of the phoenix 12.he has got the weasley family 13.he is not adopted and edward is 14.he doesnt sparkle in the sunshine 15.he has Friends 16.HARRY IS THE BEST!! 17.he has l’amour all a round him.
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
LIES!!! toi FEED US LIES!!!!
zoohi posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »