répondre à cette question

Critical Analysis of Twilight Question

is there too many anti's here and not enough balance?

ive been looking around and it seems like there is way plus anti's then twilighters around here. every question i see is like, "what is the most stupid thing about twilight?" ou "why do people like such crap like twilight?". i never saw anything positive really. everyone says that this is not just an anti spot. but from how many anti's there is here and anti questions ou picks, it really just seems like it is. now don't pounce on me. i just feel very lonley because of it.
 Twilight_Dream posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Réponses

mandapanda said:
I can understand what you're saying to a degree. There are many antis on here, but we must commend them for a few things. Alot of the antis I have talked to know alot about Twilight. They know the characters and it seems that they are genuinely curious as to why so many people like the livres and the movies.

toi are right that there are alot of antis on here, but if toi can't really handle the ~negative picks, then toi can just skip over them :) That's what I do! Or, I may just slip in and say a thing ou two :P

There are also alot of people here who had been fans since the beginning, but the movies/recent explosion of the series ruined it for them. They've had time to re-evaluate the series and analyzed and seen the flaws. Nothing is perfect in this series, even Edward :P They note the corniness, the dependancy of characters, the complete illogic of the series and calmly discuss. That's the pure intention of this spot. :)

The C.A.T. spot is for everyone who is fed up with, loving, used-to-love, hating, etc, Twilight. Those who like Twilight can't really express their opinion because alot of the newer fans tend to yell at them! I'm sure we've all experienced that! If we have a different opinion than them, they tend to call us names ou whatever. And this spot is simply to escape that. I'm fans of both the Twilight spot and C.A.T. because, if I need a break from the fangirls over at the Twilight spot, ou if I want to debate a little, I head on over to this spot. :)

I have had plus than enough conversations with these lovely cats, and they don't scratch ou claw at me for liking ou defending Twilight. Although, they keep their claws sharp, every conversation I've had here is usually civil.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
i feel like if i say one thing that is wrong in someone else's opinion i'm going to be pounced on. i feel like i can't even be myself and voice what i really think.
Twilight_Dream posted il y a plus d’un an
*
only because toi guys make it awesome! *blushes*
mandapanda posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Awww! *Blushes as well* toi are too sweet to us!
LadyLilith posted il y a plus d’un an
Dearheart said:
*puts on her LOLcats accent* liek nooooo teh kittehs wont pountz on u cuz we wuvs u!!!!11

(Ow, typing that hurt my brain...)

ANYWAY. *gives an Extra Big Momcat Snug* I totally sympathize with you. It can be hard and discouraging when you're outnumbered. (Try being a conservative on the débats spot, lol).

And I agree that we need plus balance. That's why I'm so glad toi decided to join! We need plus people like toi here! ^__^

Here's how I personally see it - it's not that there are too many antis. There just aren't enough Twilighters...not many who will really speak out for their side, anyway. I think what happens is that most Twilighters who come here either leave in disgust as soon as they see all the criticism and anti stuff, ou they rejoindre up but feel too intimidated to really speak up and just fade quietly into the background while the antis do all the talking.

So that's why it kinda looks like an anti spot right now. Am I making sense? xD Besides reaching 1000 fans, one of my biggest goals for the CAT is getting enough mature, thoughtful pro-Twilighters to come over here, stick up for their side and even out the débats a little. I think that would be a huge, awesome accomplishment for the CAT if it ever happened...

But I'm rambling. =P Anyway, if you're feeling a little discouraged par all the anti stuff, then start contributing! Add some pro-Twilight images ou write a soapbox about why you're a fan of Twilight. Stand up for what toi l’amour and give your fandom a good name! As long as toi have a good attitude about it and are willing to listen to what the other "kittens" have to say, you'll have nothing to be afraid ou ashamed of.

And respect is a two-way street. So if anyone dares to rate your stuff low ou put up nasty commentaires just because it's pro, they can go eat my shorts. (Ya hear that, kittehs? DON'T MESS WITH THE MOMCAT. SHE HAS EDIBLE SHORTS.)

Wow, that was random...
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
thank you. i will contribute.
Twilight_Dream posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Good one, MomCat! Voted toi best answer. :)
LadyLilith posted il y a plus d’un an
monLOVEbrucas said:
Dont wanna sound like a bitch, but this is a Cat spot, and this is the only place where people can get there feelings out about what they dont like.
Where else are they gonna do it... on the twilight spots? No. because people will bitch.

I like twilight, but i like this spot more, im so sick of how overrated it has become and really this is the spot were u come to escape from everyone always talking about twilight and peoplee complaining with others....
Really i dont think there should be a balance, but thats IMO
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
well i was told this is not just a venting spot for anti's, that this is where both anti's and twilighters can come to talk about it in a respectfull way. and i dont want to be rude, but if toi want to get AWAY from twilight then why did toi rejoindre this club? this is all about twilight.
Twilight_Dream posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Because this spot isnt al "OMG I l’amour EDWARD CULLEN, OMG BELLA AND JACOB BELONG" Its actually somewhat sane people. I dont even come on this spot often, but wen i want a good laugh i come here.
monLOVEbrucas posted il y a plus d’un an
*
toi just hear from the Twihaters plus often.
LadyLilith posted il y a plus d’un an
LadyLilith said:
I concur that there is certainly plus anti content on this spot than pro Twilight content. But as MomCat said, the Twilighters don't speak up as they should. We want them to, we want to have a friendly débats with them. We don't even have to debate, we can just discuss and be buddiez. :) Talking to someone with very different tastes and ideals than me in a civilized manner is like crack to me. I l’amour it, it's so fascinating.

The thing is though, that the people that l’amour this series aren't speaking up. I personally dislike Twilight, but I WANT to talk to Twilighters. I may be anti, but I have no qualms against talking to people who like Twilight. I want to see how things are going on the other side of the fence.

I can understand that toi may feel intimidated, though, par speaking of your l’amour for Twilight in front of a bunch of anti's in fear of getting gang-raped, beaten, and left in an alley (like on other spots I know hurhur). That's perfectly understandable. But toi have nothing to worry about here, I promise toi that. I will defend anyone, pro ou anti Twilight, that gets ganged up on and/or treated nastily. So have no fear; so long as you're nice to us, we'll be nice to you. And the world goes round.

And if you'd like to be friends, par all means say so!<3
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
OceanCoast said:
We're not gonna pounce on you.

The people here may be in majority 'anti' but most are respectful to Twilight fans if they wished to participate in a real discussion about the series rather than a never ending discussion on how "sPArkly anD Hawt iZ eDwarD cOMpared 2 JacOB? The people here wish to engage in an intelligent conversation about the series (both good and bad aspects) rather than a full paragraph about Jacob's 6-pack.

I'm also not gonna lie and say there isn't any negative content about Twilight, because there certainly is. This is because the series isn't for everyone and yet 24/7 its being shoved in our faces whether we like it ou not. Anti's should be able to have their say just as the pro-Twilight people get to have there's, and the difference here is that they know they won't get attacked par the 'Twilight fangirl army' if they decide to vent their negative opinion on the subject.


select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
snoznoodle said:
I agree with everyone else. We won't pounce we l’amour to hear different opinions. Nothing like a good ol' different point-of-view to start a new discussion topic. I don't call myself anti (although I'm not a fan) and there are still aspects of the livres I like. Maybe this spot is like everything else - people have a habit of focussing on the negative rather than the positive. We do need to fix the balance. I'll remember to support what I like about the series and we need plus fans to rejoindre as well. I find discussion WAY plus interesting than intimidation and one-sided opinions.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
Book_freak said:
I'm an anti myself (spare me!) and i believe anti's gravitate to this spot because it's CRITICAL of twilight. I personally do not like the reasoning that 'Twilight sucks, cos it just does' because that sounds like a 5 an old wrote it and has no reasoning behind it. I think there should be some plus fans on here to keep the arguments interesting. :)

I also think that if toi balance out the number of twihards on the Twilight spot compared to the number of anti's then it evens out.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
I agree with toi on just hating it just becuase. I am a Twilight fan, not one of the crazy, obsessed, gets offended at every thing everyone says fans, but I do like the books. And I hate it when people can't give a reason to why the hate/like something.
italiangirl976 posted il y a plus d’un an
MadamOcta13 said:
Sorry if it seems that way. It's just that if antis don't find a way to vent, we might just snap! I mean, anti clubs aren't allowed, this club welcomes antis, and it hasn't been deleted yet, so...
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
next question »