répondre à cette question

Critical Analysis of Twilight Question

My apology for being a crazy anti-Twilight. This cartoon is meant to be funny not hurtful

Im sorry. I will TRY and control myself, but I see twilight everywhere I go. I hear girls squealing about it, its on every magazine Hot Topic has a shit-load of Twilight stuff, and I think to myself, Why are they giving in to such stupidity. WE ALL are not Twilight fans so why is it everywhere and it bugs me that I even see it on the internet. Girls changing there screen names to some twilight based name. ou I am a Literature freak and a Disney freak and I hated it when some chick had the nerve to compare Twilight to the great works of William Shakespeares Romeo and Juliet ou Walt Disneys Beauty and the Beast. I mean come on I l’amour Harry Potter and I am a big freak about that but it doesnt control every aspect of my life. Peace out.
 My apology for being a crazy anti-Twilight. This cartoon is meant to be funny not hurtful
*
Okay, the internet part came out wrong, of course its going to be on the internet but I meant screen names eveywhere.
MrsEric_M posted il y a plus d’un an
*
THis pic is HILARIOUS!!!!!!
Zina17 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
I agree with everything toi put here.Ive seen that pic before and it never ceases to entertain me.Lets just hope Belle thinks hes dumb for picking up the wrong book
PoisonRose posted il y a plus d’un an
 MrsEric_M posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight  meilleure réponse

mandapanda said:
All right, first of all, being a pretty huge twilight fan, i find what toi a dit rather unpleasant. Not that I can't deal with the criticism, but I can understand how some fans will react to your analysis. Regular Twilight fans, such as myself, try not to let the harsh opinions of those who don't like Twilight, get to us. I mean, there are alot of antis, and I can deal with that. We deal with the haters, the trashers, the antis everyday. I think its only fair that toi do the same.

There are many antis whom I have enjoyed talking to. Just because I like Twilight, it doesn't mean I have to hate all those who don't like it. We don't agree sometimes, but we always are able to come to a compromise ou middle ground.

Calling liking Twilight "giving in to such stupidity", that's rather unclassy. I'm sure toi can find a better way of voicing your opinion. We all like different things. That's what makes us different.

Since Twilight is in the spotlight at the moment, there's always two sides to a coin. People are going to hate it and some who are going to l’amour it. I agree, alot of the fangirls get annoying. I too have to put up with that every day, but when the fad is done and gone, it'll be fine. It's just like the Jonas Brothers and Miley Cyrus. They were/still are a fad. I can voice my opinion par saying it's childish ou whatever, but calling the fans "childish", it's not right. Those fans find something in them [Jonas Brothers/Miley Cyrus] that is special. Us Twilight fans find something in the story that is special to us ou is meaningful. So calling us stupid, your calling our beliefs stupid. Not only our logic of why we like the story, but you're calling any of our beliefs stupid. The sane twilight fans like it for a reason. And calling us stupid, it's like your calling everything we believe in stupid.

However, I personally find the macro hilarious. It's someone's way of voicing their opinion. There's a difference between saying that about one certain object and calling all those who like it stupid.

Last year, Kevin Smith, well known writer/producer, mentioned 'Twilight' during his panel at Comic Con 09 (The New Moon Panel was a little bit earlier). Alot of people in the crowd started booing. He said, "No, stop stop." Then said,

"That's what I l’amour about a comic book invention. Here's this one person standing there in a Spock costume and looks over there to someone in a chewie costume and says, 'Look at that geek.'"

He's implying that we all like different things. Those who insult Twilight, who find us geeks ou "retarded", may like étoile, star Trek, and that's what we think is geeky and nerdy.

We all have our tastes and likes. It's not right to belittle someone when they think differently than you.

PS. My apologies for saying "stupid" so much. Lol. I was trying to make a point.

select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
I like it too! And not because I'm an anti. Actually, I'm surprised no fan has still used it as an argument in favor of Twilight: 'Gaston's an idiot, he can't appreciate the series ;)"
Plenilunio posted il y a plus d’un an
*
if u dont like the pic thats one thing but u made an answer that a dit things like shes calling those who like twilight childish she never a dit that twisting ppl's words because u dont like the pic isnt a point ou ur opinion its harsh and a way 4 u to put her down just because u dont hold the same interest in twilight
smg09 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Did toi even read my answer? I a dit I found the picture hilarious. And how am I twisting her words? I took them literally. I'm sure alot of people here did the same. So, how am I in the wrong? And, again did toi read my answer? I a dit that I can take the criticism. "there are alot of antis, and I can deal with that. We deal with the haters, the trashers, the antis everyday. I think its only fair that toi do the same" Her voicing her opinion about Twilight being everywhere and tired of it is fine, however, I think people who are looking at it from a different point of view, such as myself, should have a say in it as well. And I voiced my opinion. In no way was I trying to lash out at her, but her commentaire was unpleasant like I said. I'm not offended, but I do think she could have a dit this in another way, less harsh.
mandapanda posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Réponses

Cinders said:
I understand your frustrations, and toi know what? People here have the same frustrations with Twilight, including some fans of Twilight. But once again, toi have to be clear - There isn't just one kind of Twilight fan. The amount of stupid in the Twilight fan community is not exclusive to them. It spills out of the anti-Twilight community as well sometimes. Stupidity begets stupidity. I have to say, I consider myself a level-headed individual but if I'm drawn into a mud-slinging match, then I'll get down in the dirt and pound my chest too. It's been known to happen. Once every ten years ou so, but it does.

So, I guess what I'm saying is, it's OK to go overboard. If someone tells toi that they're offended, apologize and maybe clarify your meaning.

There are antis here - hardcore ones, too, who really don't like Twilight ou the phenomenon - who manage to be civil and respectful. Like I a dit before, I've seen toi around the site, even if I don't know what you're talking about, and I think you're a reasonable person. And toi are trying to apologize. So toi don't need to leave this spot ou anything. If someone gets on your case when toi don't deserve it, then others will come to your aid. Conversely, if toi misbehave, then you'll be called on it.

Like I a dit before - Voice your opinions, both pro-Twilight and anti, but don't be a dick about it. And if toi can't help being a dick (IE, mayhaps toi were pulled into the fray), then we'll try and defuse the tension.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
Twilight_Dream said:
excuse me? but in my opinion twilight isn't stupid and the people who read are not either. and im sorry that seeing twilight everywhere bugs you, but face the fact, thats the way it is. because people like twilight, there going to do things related to twilight. and thats there choice. toi might think twilight is dumb, stupid, etc. but then there could be a twilight fan who thinks something toi like could be dumb ou stupid.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
if toi dont like what toi hear why do toi come to C.A.T. toi should be at the Twilight spot. Because there are going to be people on this spot who think its stupid.Im sorry. I think its degrading for women. And gives the wrong ideas about love.
MrsEric_M posted il y a plus d’un an
*
*hugs her* Why don't toi have a cookie and take a look at the awesome material around? ;)
Plenilunio posted il y a plus d’un an
*
i like twilight to but u gotta admit some ppl blow it way out of perportion
smg09 posted il y a plus d’un an
Zina17 said:
im sorry heres another one
select as best answer
 im sorry heres another one
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
because i like that so called crap.:)
Twilight_Dream posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Haha! l’amour this picture too!
MadamOcta13 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
If kitteh thinks its crap,kitteh is right
PoisonRose posted il y a plus d’un an
Berrill2323 said:
Hilarious,
ANTI-Twlight FTW!!!! :P
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Im on Team STFU :D Go Antis!
PoisonRose posted il y a plus d’un an
smg09 said:
i like twilight but i get what u mean ppl changing their namnes on here and putting a twilight based name ou something and its all over the place i like it but im not obsessed and i would never compare it to any of the literature and works of art u mentioned and plus twilight is plus of a fantaisie for teens but some go overboard and lmao beauty and the beast pic lol
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
next question »