le film Twilight

répondre à cette question

le film Twilight Question

Don't understand Bella in Eclipse!

There's something I don't get, how can bella be in l’amour with both edward and jacob, even if we all know that her l’amour for the former is stronger?
Is it possible that part of her loved Jacob when we thought that her cœur, coeur was wholy Edward's- in new moon and twilight?
Some help, please!
It feels like she's not the same character anymore!
And Edward shouldn't he acted differently? He was betrayed, and yet he accepted that she could be in l’amour with someone else! Even if she chose him, it doesn't make any sens!

 Amirouna posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

le film Twilight Réponses

ScottishChic said:
It is possible to be in l’amour with plus than one person at a time, if it ever happens to you, you'll feel like Bella did in Eclipse. She is like, really confused about loving two people but of course, she loves Edward much more, otherwise she wouldn't have chosen him.
I don't think she loved Jacob when she was with Edward, feelings developed in New Moon. I mean, she liked him as a friend and then feelings grew, like he became her Best Friend and then she loved him as a best friend but she was too busy holding on to Edward to really come to sense with her emotions.
I think Edward should have acted differently too but, he loves her so much, he accepts everything. And also, he was saying that Jacob had tricked her, toi know par the whole Kiss me ou I'll kill myself thing. I would personally, of been edgy around her but Edward wanted her to be happy plus than anything. Like I a dit before, if toi get into a situation like this where toi are Bella ou Edward (situation wise), you'd probably do the same thing. (Make sense?)
Hope I helped a bit!!
 select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Btw, please no one give rude commentaires if toi disagree, this is just my opinion
ScottishChic posted il y a plus d’un an
*
thanks. You're answer makes a lot of sens , when toi think it possible to be in l’amour with plus than one peson at a time. Maybe it was possible when Edward wasn't there, in New Moon but in Eclipse, I thought it was weird and uncomfortable. I found Bella very fickle; one moment she was s’embrasser Jacob, the other she was telling Edward how much she loved him. I think she could l’amour both but being IN l’amour with both...I don't know! Thanks for the answer, I understand it.
Amirouna posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Yes, I thought that too but I guess because I know how it all turns out I don't mind it so much. She is fickle. I do think that it is possible to be IN l’amour with 2 people, well, I think that she is IN l’amour with Edward and she loves Jacob but she thinks that she's in l’amour with Jacob too cause in Breaking Dawn, it's no so much... if at all.
ScottishChic posted il y a plus d’un an
DarkGirl66 said:
what doesn't make any sense to you?? it's possible to be in l’amour with two persons at the same time. toi know, when edward left her she was alone and her cœur, coeur was broken so she needed someone to comfort her and jacob was a right person for it. he gave her love...
she loved edward all the time but her cœur, coeur made a small place for jacob. well, it's difficult but it happens.
her l’amour for edward is like...he's like a drug for her. he's her whole life. she has to be with him. and her l’amour for jake is like normal love.
MDR xD
 select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!