i really did love IAGPSW but i loved this episode....it had amazing bobby and dean moments :D and sam was so cute

i agree i loved the end and i loved when sam showed he still really cares for dean no matter what their issues are, in the previous episodes when something happened to dean sam never looked worried or shouted dean but in this episode he really looked worried when patrick told him that dean would be dead in a matter of minutes i was getting worried that he didnt care for dean as much as he used to but now i know that he does

still like ITGPSW more,man I loved so much that episode!!!

voted for urban legend

OMG was sooo funny when Dean came back out of the building young again, and did his little victory dance and jump spring! His smile was priceless. :D ! Bobby ‘Igit!’ haha awww!!

Hands down!!

I love the others too, except for ITGPSW. That was actually one of my least favorite episodes from season 4.

Lol Old Dean tryna pick up the maid "he's adorable" "and dangerous" "awww" hahaha