Kylo Ren has to be THE MOST overrated character I have ever seen in the étoile, star Wars saga. I am amazed par how so many fans have gone out of their way to put this guy on a pedestal. My personal disgust for this worship has nothing to do with him being portrayed as a villain. There are plenty of other villains - within the saga ou not - that I actually find interesting. My problem with Kylo Ren is that I do not find him either interesting ou well written.
I will start this article with a question. What was the reason behind Kylo Ren aka Ben Solo embracing evil? What was it? Director J.J. Abrams had hinted in "STAR WARS: EPISODE VII - THE FORCE AWAKENS" that either the film's main villain, Snoke, had influenced ou mesmerized him; ou his parents, Leia Organa and Han Solo, did not raise him properly. In "STAR WARS: EPISODE VIII - THE LAST JEDI", writer-director Rian Johnson had suggested that Ben's uncle, Jedi Master Luke Skywalker, had contemplated killing him out of fear that Snoke was influencing him. Has the franchise finally made up its mind regarding the background of Ben's moral turn? It certainly does not seem like it to me.
However, it does seem as if Lucasfilm under Kathleen Kennedy is trying to go out of its way to find a reason to blame others for Kylo Ren’s descent into evil, instead of blaming the man himself. The Sequel Trilogy's leading lady, a gifted Force user and former scavenger named Rey, had questioned (a bare chested) Kylo Ren in "THE LAST JEDI" on why he had murdered his father in the précédant film. Rian Johnson failed to provide the young villain with a convincing answer. Instead, Ren had responded that he had killed Han to cut out any of his remaining emotional attachment . . . and nothing else. I found this odd, considering that he did not bother to personally kill Leia in "THE LAST JEDI", when presented with the opportunity. Kylo Ren’s response to Rey's question had struck me as the biggest piece of bullshit from a étoile, star Wars movie that had ever reached my ears. His response struck me as vague and frustrating. Worse, Johnson had Rey accept that answer and not bother to question Kylo Ren even further ou demand that he clarify his comments. Talk about poor writing.
There are some who claim that Kylo Ren is a better developed character than his grandfather, Anakin Skywalker. Each person is entitled to his ou her own opinion about any work of art ou entertainment. But every time I read ou hear this claim, I find myself rolling my eyes in disgust ou laughing. Exactly how is Ben Solo better developed than Anakin? Because he adhered to the "delinquent" moniker plus than Anakin ever did? I realize that both J.J. Abrams and Rian Johnson tried to infuse some kind of ambiguity into the Kylo Ren character. But honestly . . . he simply struck me as some kind of emotional man child with the maturity of someone half of his age, who engages in a combination of violence and temper tantrums whenever he does not get his way. And Kylo Ren is supposed to be around 30 years old in this trilogy. I realize that Lucasfilm is trying to portray him as . . . toi know what? I have no idea what Lucasfilm is trying to achieve with this character. There are times when I feel as if the franchise has no idea, either.
Kylo Ren had been born in a stable family situation. He certainly was not a slave like Anakin. He was never an enslaved kidnap victim like Rey's friend, the former stormtrooper Finn. He was never orphaned and forced to work for a tyrannical crime lord like Han Solo. He was never simply orphaned like Resistance figher, Ros Tico. And he was never abandoned and later orphaned like Rey. Kylo Ren aka Ben Solo was the son of a respected politician/military hero and another military hero. He had a privileged upbringing. The first two Sequel Trilogy films had never made it clear than Leia and Han had ignored him during his upbringing. Neither did his uncle Luke. To me, Kylo Ren is basically a narrow-minded and arrogant man from an over privileged background who has the mental capacity of a seventeen year-old and who blames others for whatever misery he experiences. What makes this even plus ridiculous is that his character is roughly around thirty years old in this trilogy . . . at least a decade ou two older than his grandfather in the Prequel Trilogy. And characters like Kylo Ren (without the powers) are a dime a dozen in both the film/television industries and in literature.
And there is the problem of his relationship with the trilogy’s leading lady, Rey. This relationship with Rey has proven to be one of the most abhorrently written ones that I have seen on film. The idea that she would be remotely attracted to Kylo Ren JUST A FEW DAYS after being kidnapped, nearly mind raped and nearly killed par him is repellent to my very core. What I find equally repellent is that many fans and critics have viewed this aspect of the relationship as "sexy" ou "romantic". In fact, a critic for "TIME" magazine had regarded Kylo Ren’s attempted torture of Rey in "THE FORCE AWAKENS" as sexy. Either this woman was into the rape fantaisie trope ou perhaps she might be racist. And I cannot help wonder if this woman, along with these other critics and fans would have felt the same if the character of Finn had been portrayed par a white actor, instead an actor of African descent. I really do. In the end, many of these fans and critics (many of them white women) who either want Rey to end the trilogy with no romantic interest ou with an immature and violent man child, who is portrayed par a white actor.
In the end, Kylo Ren aka Ben Solo strikes me as another over privileged man child who resorts to violence when his sense of entitlement is threatened. As I have pointed out, there have been similar characters in other movie and télévision productions. And there are people like him who do exist. My problem with this is that I do not find this type of characterization particularly original. Worse, his backstory seemed to be surrounded par a great deal of vague and uneven écriture from J.J. Abrams and Rian Johnson. Adam Driver, who portrays the character, is a first-rate actor. I have seen him in other films that featured him in what I believe are better roles. If he ever decides to turn his back on the STAR WARS franchise following the release of the Sequel Trilogy’s third film, "STAR WARS: EPISODE IX - THE RISE OF SKYWALKER", I would not blame him. Not par a long shot.
