I just think he seems to be a little too dramatic and...mean-ish. And Luke is friendly in the beginning, at least.

but at least he's the right age! the girl playing Annabeth is older than the dude playing Luke. isn't that wrong???

i dont like the cast its just wrong what they're doing with it.....

I think Luke was cast well, and Percy was mediocre, but the rest of it was terrible.

have you SEEN the guy who plays Grover? *shouts into the sky* CURSE YOU, CASTING DIRECTORS!!!

i think a few of the people were ok. annabeth and grover are terrible choices, tho. and logan needs 2 b younger or he wold b perfect.

i think Logan's great, but i still thought Josh Hutchinson would be better.

pery was chosen just as well i think

Yep he has the same look as Luke, handsome yet ugly....sorry.

i think percy was cast perfectly grover was ok and annabeth didnt look the same but it didnt like ruin the movie! and i didnt really pay attention to luke

where is his scar???

i know!!!! i bet they thought, "well, people will be noticing Annabeth's BROWN HAIR, so who cares about Luke's scar?" well, we do!!

Luke and Percy are the only ones who I think were chosen well.