ok, so i created the pick.. but I really wasn't all that sure about my own aswer.
It would be devastatingly hard to make a decision like that if I were to be in peyton's shoes. But then again, if you are in Luke's situation and someone you love so dearly(picture your parents, siblings) has a good chance of dying, wouldn't you do anyting and everything in your power to prevent that?.. I guess I would be that selfish

She is really brave to go through with it knowing she could die. Leyton are gonna get through this or I will kill Mark.

i honestly think this question is hard to answer..because i think if i were in this situation i would have leaned more toward luke's side. however i think at the same time peyton is being very brave, it's part of them and peyton will give anything to make sure the world knows and i thought that showed a lot of courage and also showed how in love she is with lucas. and at the same time lucas showed how much he's in love with peyton. and don't for a second think that lucas wanted to kill his child. he simply was terrified at the thought of having to live his life without peyton, and having to raise a child that would never know their mother, i mean everytime he'd look at that child he'd see peyton, can you picture that.

but even with that being said. i don't think there is any right or wrong answer to the problem leyton faces. but i did agree with peyton when she believes they can get through anything.

and luke's not an idiot he never wanted to get rid of their baby to begin with...he was afraid can you blame the guy...and besides i think peyton will be just fine...she'd better be anyway.

i suppose the problem is in this situation is that his baby or not, ultimately the choice of having it or not is Peyton's. Besides Luke didn't take much convincing, i think more than anything he was just afraid and needed to hear from Peyton that they could do it and that if for some reason she can't that she knew he could.

I'm not sure.

i really dont know:S...Peyton is being so brave and Luke is so worried to loose her!!!!i am so torn!!i dont know....

i would most defently do what peyton did so i think she made the right choice its a hard choice to make.

I DON'T WANT THEM TO END THE PREGNANCY AND I ALSO DON'T WANT PEYTON TO DIE AT THE END THEY'VE BEEN THROUGH SO MUCH ALREADY. I JUST WANT THEM TO HAVE A HAPPY ENDING. JUST LIKE PEYTON SAID IN 6.18. I CRIED AT THE PEYTON SCENE SO MUCH. THAT'S WHY I WANT THEM BACK AT SEASON 7 WITH THEIR CUTE LITTLE BABY.

I can't say yes because realistically it wouldn't be at all wrong to save herself if there is such a great chance she could die. But at the same time i don't want to say that Luke is an idiot for giving in because 1.) he's never been able to put anything above what Peyton wants, apparently even if it's her life that is at stake... 2.) it's his child. Nobody can blame him for not wanting to lose it.


I do want to say that i think he was kinda out of character for a while there. I totally get him trying to point out the risks to Peyton, but Lucas Scott totally pushing abortion? So not in character! I said it to my mom and i hope we can all put ships aside and look at the facts:

In S1 when he wasn't even with Brooke, he made sure to let her know that he would do right by his child. He would NEVER push someone to have an abortion after finding out that his own father tried to pressure his mother to abort him. Again, i could see him putting it out there as an option and letting her know that he wouldn't fault her at all if she decided that she didn't want to risk her life... But to so aggressively push her like that, no matter what my feelings are on Peyton/Leyton, I completely agree with Peyton saying that Lucas was being a dick.

... to finish off- in the end i think that they made the right decision! because lets face it there not gonna kill her off are they!so im glad she kept it so we could have our lp baby! because i can predict whats gonna happen i can say that but in place of them where i dont have a fekin clue, i can say both sides were AWESOME, id be so confused and wouldnt have a clue!


luke was rght to want peyton over the babY! and peyton was right to not want to loose this baby! i support both of them! (L) but secretly i wanted her to keep him/her!

I agree with Laura

lol i did kinda just randomly end that huh?!

I still don't know if they are making the right choice... I really have this strong feeling that they are going to kill Peyton off... I've heard new rumors that Chad has signed on but Hilarie still isn't coming back and that obviously brings up the question of why Lucas would be back without Peyton if she isn't alive??

I mean they could pull some unbelievable crap where LP leave TH at the end of S6 and then for some reason Lucas comes back for a while without Peyton and the baby/just the baby with him... But how ridiculous would that be?!?

i think you have to be in that situation... im not sure.