I like both but more songs from WT.

Same

Very hard choise! I love both of these bands!

I adore both but Within Temptation wins for me.

WT is the best.

I love both for very different reasons, but WT can have a lot better musicianship (their guitarist knows how to shred when he wants to) and I think Sharon's a better singer. :)

Sharon definitely has more vocal range.

Wow I'm surprised to see that WT is winning. Evanescence was once very popular on fanpop.

^ I am too, Evanescence always seems to win.

Evanescence used to be my favorite band, but the only work of theirs that I really care for, now, would be their "The Open Door" album. However, Within Temptation is currently one of my favorites. :)

I like their fallen album and the open door. But WT is my favorite band (I think you already know that) and I love all their albums.