I liked the episode but it should have been MORE, you know?
The acting was so good though! :D

Meh, not at all. This is such a disappointment because there is only one episode left and I feel like this whole episode was wasted. There were just no interesting plot twists. Really, I even think that "Stranger in a Strange Land" and "Expose" are better episodes. =/ The best scene of the whole episode was the flash back to season 1 when Jack explored Adam&Eve.

I agree with the best scene being when Jack, Kate and Locke found A&E.
Worse than Stranger in a Strange Land? wow! That's harsh

I was hoping for more too,but still think it was really good.

Worse than Stranger in a Strange Land? wow! That's harsh
Haha, yeahm it's that bad!

Haha, yeahm it's that bad!
LOL! Well, let's just hope 6.16 will be better, the title sure sounds interesting

I think that "What They Died For" is gonna be much better for sure.

Wow, I thought this was one of the best episodes of the season.

excellent watch. but too vague. i was hoping they wud give some fixed answers. instead it raised more questions.

A huge Letdown!!

I'm with lost_Skater. I expected a hell of a lot more from this episode... I feel like Jacob / MIB's story could have been told in more detail. By the end of the episode I was just like "what? that it?" lol

It was good, but no where near as amazing as previous s6 episodes.

A solid B. And that scene with Jack and Kate at the caves was sooo on the nose. *Damon and Carlton start waving their hands* "LOOK! LOOK! Here's an answer that you can't debate now because we flashed back to when it was first brought up!"

And still I don't see how it raised questions, sorry :/

I'm pretty sure most people just expected this episode to be Jacob and the man in black sitting down and explaining the rules and that long ago a giant magical plate of spaghetti gave Jacob magical powers and made the island magic.

Edit: But wait where did the plate of spaghetti come from :P

it was okay, hoping for more, but i was still good. idk it felt unfulfilling, like it didnt really answer any questions but left me with soo many more so it got frustrating.

"I'm pretty sure most people just expected this episode to be Jacob and the man in black sitting down and explaining the rules and that long ago a giant magical plate of spaghetti gave Jacob magical powers and made the island magic."

I DEMAND a giant magical plate of spaghetti on a silver platter! :P

It was good but not nearly as good as some other episodes this season.

I really disliked this episode, it was worse than the Nikki/Paolo episode.

I didn't think it was that bad!! Yeah, it was a bummer having an episode like this so close to the finale. But it was stuff we need to know. And personally, I enjoyed it. Loved the way it blurred the lines between the good and bad guys like Lost always does.

I really liked this episode! I don't get why many ppl hate it! :/ I mean it's not the best episode of this season but it was really really good!

I loved this episode so much! The whole light thing was a little too much but I'm willing to overlook that.

I adore this ep. So good learning about their past

It was good but I am not very excited...