répondre à cette question

Harry Potter vs Twilight Question

Why do some Twilight fans hate Harry Potter so much?

I noticed on the Twilight spot, someone posté this question, "Which one is better: hp ou TWILIGHT?" and he/she a dit HP is boring and retarded, etc etc. Well, I just have to ask, why all the hate? I understand that different people have different opinions but I just have to ask. People say, "hp's gay," ou "hp is boring," but why? If toi find it boring, then there's no need to keep on ranting about it!! Seriously, Twilight fans, why so much hate? And BTW how is HP retarded? (Whoever a dit it.)
*
Aand.. vice versa? why do we hate each other so much?
ClaireVoyant posted il y a plus d’un an
*
@ClaireVoyant I think Potterheads hate Twihards because they always seem to say one's better than the other and we don't always agree? I dont't really know. But I don't hatw Twilight I was just basically asking, that's all...
cuteypuffgirl posted il y a plus d’un an
*
what harry potter is so awesome!!! i much better than twilight but twilight is still good but harry potter is better
annabell9122 posted il y a plus d’un an
 cuteypuffgirl posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Harry Potter vs Twilight Réponses

cassie-1-2-3 said:
Again, disliking Harry Potter has nothing to do with Twilight for a lot of people. (There are people who don't like either, toi know?)

The only reason toi saw Twilight fandom as a common factor in the people who insulted HP is because the question was in the Twilight spot. Go to any other book series, movie, ou télévision montrer spot and compare it to Harry Potter and you'll be compelled to ask "Why do Glee fans hate Harry Potter. One of them a dit it's lame and boring, but why the hate?"
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
avrilsmylife said:
1st its not all twilight fans. i l’amour twilight and harry potter but twilight more.
2nd i also wonder why all the hate. it makes no sence to hate on another film because i bet the actors dont fight like this
3rd it may just be there opinion to call hp retarded which i know is stupid to say but if it what they think and like toi kinda have to respect it xx
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
thanks, and i did say SOME twilight fans, but I respect your opinion! :)
cuteypuffgirl posted il y a plus d’un an
*
haha thanx i also l’amour Harry Potter i just dont understand why people have to hate on each other
avrilsmylife posted il y a plus d’un an
*
One person insults the fans of another famous book, then all of the insulted lashes back in outrage-- a viscious cycle in this spot. :S
traceyhp posted il y a plus d’un an
justingurl99 said:
uhh i don't know. I guess twilight fans are just jealous of the HP fans, donné the fact that HP is a lot plus successful. I don't know really. I actually liked the first Twilight movie, but the other ones... Too much l’amour involved. There is no reason for all the hate, but it's just that there's a war going on and we can either keep fighting ou we settle this out peacefully.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
alisonfaith297 said:
its not all twilight fans and it is vice versa. for me, i think hate is a strong word, i would rather say dislike. i dislike the series personally. i have my reasons but this is not my point for the question. the thing is the history behind this huge feud is unclear. thats the whole point. actually. because there is no clear point we just defend whatever side we are on. some people actually engage in actually debates which dont included statements like Hp is retarded. which i think in literary terms is a good thing. basically its like and online book club. the important thing to note is that the hate that bugs people comes from arguments par people who have not even read and/or either series. they just argue for the sake of it.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
also one plus point, there is some crossover between twi and HP like rob patterson etc. some even have theories that meyer ripped off some of JKR storylines.. etc..
alisonfaith297 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
I agree with every single word u wrote there! :)
cuteypuffgirl posted il y a plus d’un an
peppergirl30 said:
Speaking as a fan of both, I would have to say that I think we fight because:
1. It's the two biggest films in the last couple years
2. Because of number one, we're always trying to out do each other
3. Because Twi-Hard's and Potterheads have been in war for a long time :(
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
FF1: Fandom Fight 1. When will the vfighting end?? It's getting annoying!
cuteypuffgirl posted il y a plus d’un an
*
I feel the same way, but no one knows.
peppergirl30 posted il y a plus d’un an
mangie1995 said:
Basically toi have the hardcore fans of one fandom and the hardcore fans of another and like most hardcore fans they believe the thing they l’amour is the best so some of them are blinded away from the logic of "why the f**k am I even having this argument when nobody really gives a crap?" par their intense l’amour for their favourite series and become intent in trying to prove their point even though the person their arguing with is never going to see that point due to posessing the exact same intense l’amour for their favourite series, hence the huge feud between the fandoms.

Although I believe it's kind of OK to have that on this spot since it's a "VS" spot and therefore basically implies some kind of battle, this spot was pretty much made for this feud. :P
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
koolkat2563 said:
well i say harry potter is lame because who like s wizards i mean he have done porno and he is retared and we are geting tired of the mom and dad story he parents are gone in moive why keep bring them back and twilight is better and glacière because something that is populaire vampires vs werewolfs are cool wizards vs wizards are lame and also if toi did not get the memo he has porno and he is gay
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
First it wasn't a 'Prrno' it was a PLAY. Secon he is not 'Gay' and if he was what difference does that make, he is still a human. and par the way wizards taking over the world and killing hundreds of innocent people is plus interesting than some girl falling in love, getting married and having a weird baby with her sparkly 'vampire' boyfriend (late husband). And the whole 'parents thing' is essential to the story, would toi forget a woman who died to save you?
theelderwand posted il y a plus d’un an
*
I wasn't talking to you.
youknowit101 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
toi a dit you're both so I thought toi were. Sorry 'bout that bro.
zanhar1 posted il y a plus d’un an
mr-cullen said:
no.....there are huge no of HP fans who hate twilight ,what about that.......
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
I understand where you're coming from, but the twi-hards were also attacking other fandoms which caused the high numbers of antis. So it's plus than Harry Potter fans that are actually against these specific fans of the saga and/or the saga itself. It's actually a lack of respect and the editor's/reviewer's commentaires about twilight versus everything that started it all in the first place. Sorry about the lengthy comment, but this is why twilight is met with negativity. So sad, but so true. :S
traceyhp posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »