répondre à cette question

Harry Potter vs Twilight Question

Why do people actually like Twilight?

C'mon everybody I don't want reasons like:

OMG Edward/Jacob is so hot!
Bella is sooooo cool!
The plot is sooooo easy to understand(in other words plain boring)

But really guys, I always wondered, why do toi all like Twilight? What is so good about a creepy stalker that sparkles...not to mention Bella is a whiny bitch!

Be realistic, and don't get mad at me for hating it..I just want to know what is so good about it?
*
I honestly have no clue MDR I guess because of the "romance" and maybe the characters *shrugs*
Ms_Mea posted il y a plus d’un an
*
I added my reasons
TrueTwi_hard posted il y a plus d’un an
*
nobody knows!!!!!!
stipidtwihard posted il y a plus d’un an
 RavenclawRocks posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Harry Potter vs Twilight Réponses

cassie-1-2-3 said:
No worries. toi most likely won't get any réponses like that.

I like it becuase of its relateability. Not to Bella, but to the series as a whole. Many people will say it's unrelateable, but through some crazy series of miraculous events, I happen to somehow relate to it a lot..
I see a lot plus to the story of Twilight other than a girl and some vampires with some wolves, so I don’t need any vampires ou loups in my life to relate.

This does not then that the characters are my rolemodels. This does not mean that Twilight has taught me any life lessons either. I do not want to be taught life lessons. I just want something to relate to.
toi guys know nothing about my life and I don’t want toi to, so I can’t get into the necessary detail to help toi fully understand.
To déplacer past what it is I need to recover from, I don’t need some book to tell me how I should live ou to guide me to the needed result. I first need to find that I am not aloneand Twilight has done this in many was I couldn’t even imagine. It’s helped me sort out various things about myself and help me understand things I didn’t before. It’s also helped me learn thing about myself I wasn’t even aware of.

There are various minor details that I relate to in a sentimental way, in addition to the big story.
The contemporary vibe of the Cullen home
Carlisle’s career
Carlisle’s relationship with people
Bella’s schooling
Taste in music
Taste in lire materials
Taste in clothing
Certain abilities some of the vampires have
Hair
Lifespans

I admire Edward’s values a great deal. This is the main thing.
I admire Carlisle’s strength a great deal.

It’s all sentimental for me.
I don't appreciate when people tell me that I shouldn't like it becuase my reasons aren't good enough for them. My reasons are my own reasons. I like Twilight for myself. I'm not liking it for somebody else.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
I totally get you! People look at me like I have a bird on my head when I explain why I like twilight. My reasons are here too, and they're completely different, but I get you. Good comment, and briliant reasons. I do want to be taught live lessons, but that doesn't say my reasons suck. I l’amour yours.
TrueTwi_hard posted il y a plus d’un an
*
What the heck is she(?) going on about? Is it bad that I didn't understand a word she(?) said?
frankthe2nd posted il y a plus d’un an
*
stipidtwihard, toi should respect other people's reasons. I'm in high school too, and cassie isn't ''some kid''. Cassie has better reasons than most other. What are your reasons? Because jacob is hot?
TrueTwi_hard posted il y a plus d’un an
TrueTwi_hard said:
Twilight changed my way of looking at things. Sure... It's not real, but the book made me look at my oppinion. My whole life would be different if it wasn't writen. I'm not one of those Twilight fans who only care about how hot Robert Pattinson is. The book changed me, not the movie. The twilight serie is a wonderful life-lesson wraped in a beautiful storie. I'm glad Miss. Meyer wrote it. These are my main reasons:

I like twilight because of the storyline, the sentences and the actions.
When I read twilight, i think of my choises, and what I would do. I think of how I montrer my loved ones that I l’amour them, and I think about what I would do for true love.
When I read New Moon, I think about what I would do for the people i truly love. And I realize, that I would hurt myself. I would do everything for them. I know that I would make sure they are happy, and if that's par making myself ripped apart, I would happily be ripped. I would match them to my enemies, if that's the way to make them feel love, without being hurt.
When I read eclipse, I imagen how it would be to be on the same front as my enemy, and I have desited, that it doesn't matter. As long as being on that front, would make sure my loved one is save, I would go through eveything, see them Kiss in every possible way, just to make sure she won't get hurt.
When I read Breaking Dawn, I realize, ones again, That I would happily live through every pain people can imagen, to l’amour my loved ones. When that means that my ribs are broken, my lungs half beaten and my stumach ripped apart, I would be glad. That means I'm still alive to see my loved ones. I would welcome death, if it saved my family.
The whole sage, makes me think about life, and how less I care about my own. I think, and I know, that, as long my loved ones are still alive, I would walk straight in the arms of death.

It makes me look at my live because I imagen myself in her live. When I do that, I see the things I do wrong. I see what I should, and would, do for everybody around me. Bella is quite selfish. When I read Eclipse for the first time, I realized I am too. I wás quite selfish. Now, I ask my family and Friends to tell me when I go that way again. It helps. I'm not that selfish anymore. A lot of Bella's bad things I have to. When I read her mistakes, I see what I can do to don't make them myself.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
The sacrifice is strong. Very heartfelt reasons.
cassie-1-2-3 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
it messed up your life!!!
stipidtwihard posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Well, yeah toi can say you'd die for your loved ones and the rest...but when it comes down to actually dieing, ou hurting ourselves, I doubt hardly any of us would actually be as willing to do it as toi say. But nice reasons, much better than the genral pathetic attemps to defend Twilight.
RavenclawRocks posted il y a plus d’un an
bri-marie said:
Some people like the general story, the romance, the characters, Smeyer's écriture style. Some people can relate to the characters, ou like the messages (there are actually some good messages in Twilight).
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
I like your icone
ros59 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
all lies
stipidtwihard posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Um, no.
bri-marie posted il y a plus d’un an
youknowit101 said:
Remember I'm a guy

I don't mind romance. I'm not the most typical guys that needs action and killing to be satisfied. I don't like violence. Twilight had some action, and it was enough for me.
I liked all the characters for their smarts and choices.
I think Edward is a good example of how a man should act. He shouldn't be so controlling, but he should stand up to a girl sometimes and say what's on his mind too. Avoiding confrontation is what causes everything to go wrong with a lot of couples.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
toi are like the boyfriend I want,we could be together but age is way apart,I will always want a boy ou man that l’amour Twilight as much as I do.
ros59 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
^LoL >.< x
Italktosnakes posted il y a plus d’un an
*
And?
youknowit101 posted il y a plus d’un an
ros59 said:
because we do,we can like it and Jacob,Cullens,Bella,Renesmee.
Don't question its power.
Better people that want to argue and say because we do is not a reason it is,happy now???!!!

select as best answer
 because we do,we can like it and Jacob,Cullens,Bella,Renesmee. Don't question its power. Better people that want to argue and say because we do is not a reason it is,happy now???!!!
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
b/c u do? not a reason
luv_warriorcatz posted il y a plus d’un an
*
^^^^^ "Stipidtwihard" toi spelled "stupid" wrong.....was that on purpose?
woofbark posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Wow. toi can do it like those people. Now, your reasons please?
RavenclawRocks posted il y a plus d’un an
LinaHarrow said:
Don't question the motives of Sarah. -_-

Just kidding.

But siriusly.

Simply put, I like the plot. I find the idea interesting, and the characters amusing and intriguing.

Any Questions?
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Yes.
woofbark posted il y a plus d’un an
*
question no.1: Why did toi find the characters intriguing? (I liked the history of Carlisle and Esme)
woofbark posted il y a plus d’un an
*
2. Well written, it had excitement, romance, action, betrayal, (Princess Bride flashback moment yet again), it was an interesting idea, fantaisie meets reality, yet written in a way that wasn't totally far-fetched (as in horribly).
LinaHarrow posted il y a plus d’un an
Italktosnakes said:
Umm...
'Cause it's fit'
'Cause it's well realistic'
'Cause I can't find my HP ou PJO books, and my computer's out. This is the suivant best thing'
'Cause my Mom didn't want me to read it'
:D x
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
MDR
RavenclawRocks posted il y a plus d’un an
delena91 said:
yeah, why?
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
read some other réponses
youknowit101 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
this off subject but I like your icone delena91
ros59 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
I am just plain curious.
RavenclawRocks posted il y a plus d’un an
*
i think i was drunk when i wrote this answer because i don't remember i did. In fact the correct aswers should be, i ask the same. I don't understand either why people like twilight that much so i understand you're curious
delena91 posted il y a plus d’un an
AllyAM said:
I used to like it because it was a bit of an escape from my everyday life (which was not really great at that time) Most of it was, I read them because my Friends kept bugging me too, I got caught up it the hype of it all. It seemed adventurous enough, but after a while I was disappointed par the unchanging characters, decisions made par them, not to mention plot holes I came across (I cannot remember exactly what they were now...) That's most of why I liked them, ou used to, at least.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
Cheygirl said:
I think for me (when I loved it) was because it was a romance story and some of the characters like the Cullens (minus Edward and Bella), Seth Clearwater, and Charlie. I also like the Nomad group (:
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
hpgods said:
Ok, who deleted my answer???
All I a dit was that i don't think these people are telling the truth! They sound too much like Harry potter fans

I don't like Twilight. I don't know why anyone does. They think everyone is hott
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
It was probably deleted because toi called everyone stupid liars. This is a little better, I guess, but please realize that Harry Potter fans are not above ou smarter than Twilight fans, ou vise versa. Each person is an individual who deserves just as much respect as toi do.
cassie-1-2-3 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
fanpop deleted your answer. Most likely because toi were rude and didn't actually answer the question.
bri-marie posted il y a plus d’un an
*
LolNO. All the Twilight actors are fugly in my opinion.
LinaHarrow posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »