répondre à cette question

Harry Potter vs Twilight Question

I have a question for Twilight fans. Many of toi say toi prefer Twilight over Harry Potter. But none of toi ever say why. I would like to know why.

toi say "Twilight is better," but never give any valid reasons why toi feel that way. toi never back yourselves up. Give me a REAL reason why toi think Twilight is better. All over the internet Harry Potter fans are giving valid reasons why they prefer Harry Potter. Now it's your turn. And I don't want any stupid answers. None of this "the characters are hotter" crap because that's not a real reason. It dosn't have anything to do with the quality of the story.
 PotterForever posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Harry Potter vs Twilight  meilleure réponse

sapherequeen said:
Well, I can't really say I like Twilight better because I haven't read Harry Potter except for the first book. What I can do, though, is give toi reasons as to why I really like Twilight. :)

1) Twilight has very interesting characters, for example; Rosalie Hale. To briefly summarize her artistry: She may appear vain, bitter, and at times cold on the outside, but on the inside she really does have a cœur, coeur of Gold. It may seem like Rosalie really detests Bella, but she truthfully only wants to help her and for Bella to choose what Rosalie believes is the truly right choice for her. Then there's Leah, who is quite similar to Rosalie's character. There are also other characters such as Jasper, Emmett, the Volturi (although I don't like the Volturi, others do), and for most fans Bella and Edward themselves.
2) The romance. Twilight is actually one of the only two romance stories I like (the seconde is ROmeo & Juliet). When I first read Twilight, the l’amour between Edward and Bella sometimes blew me away. It gave me a deep look into l’amour and what someone could do for their significant other that was very fascinating to me.
3) vampires are in it! I'm a fanatical Vampire fan, I'm sorry! xD
4) The way Stephenie wrote the series allows readers to be able to place themselves in Bella's shoes, and experience Bella's, Edward's, and the other characters' stories themselves. That's always a plus from me. :)
5) A lot of people may disagree with me on this, but it is a very big reason as to why I like Twilight; it shows that someone can go from ordinary to quite famous and well-known. Stephenie was an ordinary housewife before she had the dream and wrote Twilight. Once she was done écriture the first novel in the series and published, she rose from everyday stay-at-home mom to one of the world's most popular, bestselling author. It, in a way, shows toi that anyone can be successful and have incidents that are truly amazing & fortunate happen to toi at any point of your life. :)

These are some of the reasons why I do have a strong fondness for Twilight.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
finally, a twilight fan who can form a complete sentence! (no offense intended)
FredWRules posted il y a plus d’un an
*
i am avampire fan
Chanaly101 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Me too, Chanaly101 :)
sapherequeen posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Réponses

Hiplop said:
because anyone who enjoys twilight, are under the age of 12 and are opinionless mouton, moutons who follow whatever the most populaire thing is...
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
That's just rude. First of all, I'm fifteen. Not a "twelve-year-old mindless sheep". Yet I somehow like Twilight. 2) Why can't toi respect others' opinions? toi don't see any Twilight fan on this page (I admit, I can't speak for the whole site) offending toi because toi like Harry Potter. So why are toi giving this treatment to us? 3) It's not that Twilight is popular. There are plenty of reasons as to why someone may like the Twilight series other than its popularity, just look at the other réponses to this question. Please don't be judgmental towards Twilight fans, not all of them are crazy and obsessive.
sapherequeen posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Not all Twilight fans are like that. A lot of them though.
PotterForever posted il y a plus d’un an
*
one of my frinend thats 15 likes twight but she real smart but she liked harry potter frist but she has never read the harry potter livres sad but all ends well
june13 posted il y a plus d’un an
ladywyze said:
toi don't need any reason why toi liked a thing. Its just, your mind liked this thing. Me, I'm a twiheart, and I don't really know why. Cause why should I know? It's my taste, and toi can't say anything bout it!!1 ha!!!!!

Okay. It wasn't scary. When I first watched Twilight 1, I first thought it was a horror story. Because indicating vampires and werewolves. But it wasn't. and this is how I ended.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
So, toi have no reason?
PotterForever posted il y a plus d’un an
*
This answer has a lot of nothing in it.
LifesGoodx3 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
i know what that meant. she likes twilight because.. NOTHING. Nothing compared to Harry Potter.
avadakedavra posted il y a plus d’un an
KylilovesTaylor said:
I l’amour Twilight plus because i read all the livres and i feel like i am one of the charecters. Such as I would think that i am really in the book instead of lire it. And i still do like harry potter too, it's just i l’amour Twilight.And i would like to know are toi a Twilight fan ou harry potter?
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
toi feel like you're one of the characters? Which one? And... Why?
LifesGoodx3 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Probably Bella. She's an empty shell. It's easy to be her.
RavenclawPride posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Meyer actually a dit in an interview that she left out lots of personality details and stuff so that her readers could preted to be the characters.
Bellatrix-Black posted il y a plus d’un an
MariposaPhoenix said:
First of all, I like Twilight. So I guess I must be a mindless sheep.



To be honest, I don't know how I got into Twilight. I remember hearing all these people talk about it and I was like "What's the big deal? vampires and romance. So what?" But then a friend of mine who loves paranormal stuff read them and a dit they were pretty good and so I read them and I was hooked. But thats what happened with me and Harry Potter. I hated it and then I read it and started to like it. Anywho, I guess they appeal to me because the characters such as Rosalie and Jasper are so little used but their characters backstories were so powerful. I also seemed to like how the romance and mytholigy were brought together. When HP fans look at it they're like "Oh, the vampires are sparkly! They probaly run around like little pixies all jour long". I agreed until I read 'Secret Short Life of Bree Tanner' and its my favori in the series now. Because Meyer showed the darker side of the vampires. Not the pixie ones, the people killing, murderous barbarians they are. It really made me think twice about the series.

If toi don't get what I'm saying then I guess I really must be a mindless mouton, moutons after all. I am trying to say this in a mature way. My opinions.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
Roxyrose007 said:
I really l’amour Twilight,but I l’amour Harry Potter even more.
I just think it's a bit plus interesting.
Do not take me wrong,please,I respect Twilight and Harry Potter fans both,and really don't see a reason to argue 'which one is better',or 'which one has plus interesting and deeper characters'.
That's just stupid.
The reason I like Twilight is that it's not like the other vampire books.It's unique and fresh,and very interesting,too.
The same is for Harry Potter: It's not just a wizard book.
It's a whole new world between the covers and that's what makes it good.
toi see,Twilight and Harry Potter are so simmilar,I don't see a reason for arguing.
I hope some of toi agree with me.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
peewee7 said:
Because even though I like Harry Potter, I l’amour twilight! Twilight is newer, and involes a new fantasy: vampires & WEREWOLVES
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
How's that a "newer fantasy"? There's nothing new about a book being written about vampires and shapeshifters.
bri-marie posted il y a plus d’un an
*
toi know, the whole piont of this question was to get people to give actual reasons, Twilight being newer is not a reason, and Vampire and werewolve storys have been around for ages.
PotterForever posted il y a plus d’un an
misukikoyama said:
harry potter has a plot where as twilight is a romance novel harry potter has action and twilight does too but the action is different and the same hp its the action is about good guys against bad guys twilight is were loups against vampires plus voldemort is supposed to represent adolf hitler because hitler was half jewish and he went after the world but was famous for the jews btw im jewish :) and voldemort wants the world also anyone against him dies but he is plus famous agaisnt muggles and hes half muggle.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
next question »