I might of voted for BatB if it wasn't for that banana tree dress

Both were a bit underwhelming, to be honest.

I enjoy them both i find the romance in aladdin was better done but batb effect > aladdin effect Gaston and lefou >> >>jafar.

Edit : i totally missed the point of the question so change my mind a whole new world ! Even if both didnt have good effect in beauty and the beast there was no emotion.

Both are rather blah so....

I can't even chose, I thought they were both so bad. I enjoyed Aladdin a lot more but this scene was so rushed and not magical at all. I wish they had more build up to the song like the violins in the original and a more beautiful view of the world while flying. In Beauty and the Beast the castle was nice, a little too dark. But the dress was bad. The scene was terrible and extremely unemotional compared to the original.

Just ugh. But B&TB live action turned out worse in my opinion.

Both were very much inferior to the animated versions

I hate all the remakes.