Do toi think what has happened to Duncan this season been fair?

Actually......no.

I personally feel like this season has ruined every single character, and really emphasized mistreatment and unfairness for all the characters involved in the l’amour triangle.

I found it ridiculous that Duncan became so consumed in his image that he then felt the need to prove how bad he was par blowing up Chris' cottage. And I find it terrible écriture that Duncan blew up something else in an earlier season, yet he didn't go to jail then. There's a lack in continuity.

Yes, Duncan is a jerk and cheating scumbag. But was jail really necessary for him to learn a lesson??? For his crime, yes jail is the appropriate sentence; however, because he wasn't punished earlier for the same crime, this time just seems like the writers are catering to fans and punishing him for the cheating and bullying.

I'm so done with this season. The writers really screwed up.....yet again.

I always knew Duncan would go out with a bang.

However I feel like All-Stars has ruined most of my favori characters. I mean, come on.

Lightning isn't so stupid that he would get voted out in the seconde episode. And he's such an easy character to write about, theirs no reason to get rid of him so early on! I would have gotten rid of someone less entertaining, like Sam.

5th is the earliest Heather has ever been eliminated. Quite frankly I feel like the writers did that because they were too lazy to focus on Aleheather. AKA: The best Total Drama pairing EVER!

Al would never be so dumb as to tell Mal where he hid his black mail disc. And I doubt he would ever form an alliance with him. However, I did think the writers nailed Al at the beginning of All-Stars. But after Suckers Punched, the writers just got lazy with him.

Gwen and Courtney are the new Katie and Sadie.

And Scott... oh dear lord what did they do to my poor Scott. While he still has his season 4 charm, I hate how hes so consumed with Courtney. Though frankly I like the pairing, and I think everyone else would too, if it weren't so rushed.

And then toi have Duncan. Honestly, Duncan is mister big and bad, yet they make him scared stiff of Mal! No, instead of being scared of Mal, the normal Duncan we all love/hate would be plotting his revenge from what everything Mal did in juvi.

And I hate how they tried to make him into a good guy. We all know that he does indeed have a heart, so why did they have to play on that and make him look like a wimp?

*sigh* I dunno. I'm going to keep watching because of my total drama loyalty, but I hope the writers learn from this when they write season 6, which will be about another cast.

YES

Yes he's an absolute jerk!

Yep!

Defiantly. He deserved to go to real jail for that stunt he pulled. Ultimately, the writers just ruined his character and all the others. They could've used other characters for the past seasons, but no it seems like its the same damn drama every time and it's not even entertaining. It's sad because they could've used Eva ou someone else to develop their storylines instead of worrying about some l’amour triangle.

No. Even though i liked this season, i thought Sierra would of have returned with her signature long ponytail from season 3, but i guess she's okay with a short ponytail.