His biggest crime though would be creating the evil queen.

Killing Milah was a crime of passion...and she kind of deserved it.
Turning Gaston into a rose was just hilarious...especially when Belle cut the end off.
Killing the godmother was a bit harsh but that's one of my fave opening scenes from the show. I love when Rumple does such evil things XD
I laugh at the slug seen too.

And I do agree with minervadawn...I felt bad for how he and Cora manipulated Regina into becoming evil.

Killing Milah, the mother of his child Milha too. But if Rumple didn't manipulate the crap out of Gina, a lot of troubles would be made.

And thanks for making this question, after a bunch of repeat 'which Gina action is worse' questions it's nice to see someone acknowledge that there are eviler characters in Once...

I'm not even going to mind this.

Princess-Yvonne had to live this spot because of all the hate she received for making similar picks about gina's crimes.

but... yeah! I guess if we're talking about Gold is cool. If we were talking about Gina then we should have just attacked the person who made the pick.

jesh.

?

I thought we settled this...

Okay, whatever. Never mind, I won't say anything else. However, in my own defense I would like to point out that I did not yell at snowandcharming at all for making her 'which Gina crime is worse' poll only minutes before this, I simply picked my answer and commented why I didn't choose the other.

Cool. Because it is hurtful enough as it is.

What is? We made a whole forum to apologize. And you said that all was forgiven, so what's this about? What did I do this time? I'm just a little confused and caught of guard here.

I just look at questions like this and the unfairness of this club blows up in my head again. It's just so unfair.
As I've said I'll try to ignore it.

Well I guess I can understand that as I hate being treated unfairly. But isn't it fair that if people can make them about Gina others can make them about Gold? And as I pointed out, no one yelled at snowandcharming for hers and this came up recently, as in recent I mean only hours ago. Not one person even seemed mad or bothered. Most of us just commented why we chose one or another. I don't think anyone is being unfair, not anymore anyways. I'm not yelling or anything, just trying to explain.

Ignoring it is probably a good idea, I'm kind of trying to ignore some of the negative--so to speak--Gina comments, to avoid conflict.

I wasn't talking about snowandcharming's picks. I was talking about my sister's picks and how she was the one to get all the hate.
If it is perfectly fine to make them about gina, gold or whomever why was she condemned and pointed at?
Unfair.

Mostly because I can't really see the reason behind this one (and the killing the man who skinned Bae's knee). With the others, I could see the logic, the over all purpose. With the maid, it was just nonsensical violence.

^^ It has to do with that huge rivalry between the fandom. I was told it wasn't okay for me to do or comment certain things that everyone else did too. With all due respect, she wasn't the only victim. She was doing that sort of stuff to magichand and I too.

This is kind of why I wanted her to join our apology forum, to avoid stuff like this and get all of this kind of stuff sorted out.

I don't know about you, but I kind of want to end this discussion. I feel like I'm pushing you, and that we're dancing on a very, very thin line.

I never wanted to start a discussion. It just happened. The fact is she's not here now, because she is still hurt. and this doesn't seem anymore such a fun place to be for me either.

It's still kind of not that fun for me either as anything I say seems to be taken wrong, or is at risk of being taken wrong. And I still have numerous people questioning me when I state my opinions, despicably in regards to Graham. I have like 3 people against me right now. That only goes to show, that there is more than one victim here.

And it's kind of the nature of a site like this, there are so many different opinions clashing that it's hard to say anything that doesn't offend at least one person. I guess you can say that well, that's life for ya.

Anyhow, do you want to just end this discussion, seeing as you never meant to start it?

You can't take anything personally on here and if you do well then maybe you shouldn't be on a place like this. This pick wasn't made to personally attack Gold's fans so don't flatter yourself.

And quite to the contrary I see loads of picks like this aimed at Regina, they seem to be fine and dandy however when a Regina fan makes a pick aimed at Gold everyones all "Evil Regal's are out to get me".

Enough is enough if your not going to make an actual PICK then don't comment. It wasn't made to start trouble so don't stir it up.

^ Thank you. That's kind of what I was trying to explain.I'm just upset right now because I made a whole forum for this and I thought it was done with. :/

I think both blue-eyes and snowandcharming both created fair and unbiased picks focusing on the crimes of two of the shows major villains. I don't think they were targeting anyone just asking what you beleive the worst thing either of these charatures have done. None of the answers are made up. Both Rumple and Gina have done bad things. I don't think asking which ones are worse is at all out of line. In fact they are both great picks and I'd like to thank both users for creating them.

I'm also a little tried of any poll created that focuses on Gold negitive atrabutes being pasted with personal attacks and negative comments. He's not a angel people! He has done and still does bad things.

Hmm, i think ill go with this one.

^^ Well said

I concur well said minevadawn.

thank you, blue-eyes for suggesting I shouldn't be here.

now we shouldn't take it personal, right? Maybe you should all give that advice to yourselves. Go back and take a look on your comments on my sister's picks. Then her picks were wrong and your comments right. Now my comments are wrong and your picks are fine.
Hypocrisy.

Way to come in and bring up something that I swear we solved. Meh, I suppose I didn't really expect it to last.

I'm not going to dignify any further comments with a response because it's just getting ridiculously tiring. You can jump to any conclusions your little hearts desire, but I'm done. Peace.

Milah deserved to be murdered in cold blood? How sick is that? And how sexist!

Milah did deserve it. She abandoned her own son when he really needed her. Wasn't grateful that her husband was at least alive. Running away with a filthy pirate. Then cruelly confessing to Rumple that she never really loved him.