It's not one of my top concerns, but it does bug me that after Emma learned the truth about the curse that she didn't stop and go "hmm, maybe there is more to Graham's death"

I have read an artickle on the internet and i think it's true.

Emma knows everything, alright ! If we rewatch ''A Land without magic'', we will see how she asked Regina if it's true. When she learned the truth about curse, she haas started to believe in everything what Henry told her (including Graham's death). And the reason why Emma didn't punish Regina is because of Henry.

Now, can we leave this behind?

^No, we cannot. Having Emma know and not arrest Regina simply for Henry's sake would just be wrong and stupid. Regina killed an innocent man! Emma would totally throw her in jail for doing it. Plus, they only showed Emma figuring out the curse was real, if that included her realizing that Graham was murdered, then where is Emma's big emotional reaction to that piece of news? As much as some people might not want to admit it, Emma did love the man. Jennifer Morrison said so! She wouldn't just let his death slide and let his murderer get away with it. So, not getting her reaction to his death and just his death, is a total and utter cop out!

It's been a year, how can no one still have no clue?

But I still believe part of regina's redemption will be about graham, his life and death was tragic and it was all because of regina, her redemption won't be complete without some justice for graham, she will pay for her crime (I have no idea how, her life at the moment already pretty mess up, I can't imagine how her life can be more suck)

So I do think graham's story still unfinished and we will heard about him again, how long we have to wait though?

Maybe I'm just being biased but; I really don't want her to, especially if it's after they start getting along if they ever do. Gina has enough to deal with.

I can't begin to say how annoyed I'am!! I'm glad Regina is trying to change but she has to PAY for what she did to my Graham!!!

@zanhar1: So, you're saying she should just get away with his murder? How on earth is that right?

@LadyKnighton: I know! That's one of the things I don't like about the whole redemption plot line...it's like the writers are using it as an excuse to deny Graham justice.

I'm not saying that at all. What I'm saying is she's already received enough punishment. She's trying to be a better person and further disciplined and pain could easily turn her away from that goal, as such is highly discouraging. In a way being framed for Archie's death is the equivlant of her getting caught for Graham. I don't know if I explained that very well, seems like every time I explain my opinions on a matter like this it gets shot down big time and I get accused of thinking murder is okay. I don't, if that's what any of you were thinking.

Regina being punished for other crimes she committed is not the same thing as being punished for killing Graham. Murders spend years in jail, and the only time we've ever seen Regina in jail after his murder was that brief period in Broken. And the only suffering she received as a result of being framed for Archie's murder was knowing that Henry thought she did it...and that was short lived. That isn't the same thing as being held accountable for the murder she did commit.

First of all, let me just rephrase that first paragraph I typed completely, with a couple of questions; Who actually wants to see their favorite character's secret exposed? 'Who wants it exposed especially if it could get them the death sentence? Let's say this is reversed (and I am in no way accusing him of of doing or saying Graham should've done this) and Graham was the one who murdered Gina, he's your favorite character (right?) would you like to see him go to jail or be executed? I'm not in anyway trying to justify or say murder is okay, I'm just saying I'm tired of seeing Regina suffer. This whole season has been (in regards to Regina anyhow) all about Gina suffering and paying for the curse she cast. I just don't want things to start going good for her and then crap happens and it all falls apart. Who actually wants to see their favorite character suffer? And we all want our characters to have a happy ending right? That's all I want for her.

This isn't about my favorite character vs. another character. This is about justice. In real life, a murderer wouldn't go unpunished simply because "he/she has already suffered enough." If Graham had killed Regina in cold blood, I would be greatly disappointed in him, but I wouldn't want him to go unpunished.

I never said it was about that. I think the two (favorite character bias and Justice) go hand in hand, maybe not for you, but for me they do. In real life, sure lock the murderer up, it's for the best. I'd still feel a bit of sympathy for him/her but yeah get him/her off the streets. Where as with fictional characters to be perfectly honest (as a villian lover) I want them to get away with it. Even more honesty, I have a strong bias for characters I love. Correct me if I miss interprated; you asked if I wanted Regina to be found out and punished, my answer was no--for the reasons I listed above. Sorry if I sound rude at all in the above or with what I am about to say; We've all got opinions, I couldn't care less about villians getting punished in fiction (once again my veiws on real people are entirely different) where as you do. And I respect that opinion, if you want Regina punished, by all means that's fine with me, I just hope you, and others respect mine. I just kind of feel like, in general on this spot, anytime I mention any positive opinion on Regina it gets shot down or I have to explain myself where as, say, Charming fans are never questioned about their opinions.

Once again sorry if I sounded rude, and for kind of venting about my problems there. None of it was directed at you in particular.

duh! Of course I am! :,(

Has anyone else realised that when Regina killed Graham she did the exsact same thing to Emma that here mother did to her?

Oh, I have! I noticed that the first time I saw "The Stable Boy."

A little bit, but I more feel this is a slip up on the writers part than anything.

Besides. There's no logical way for Emma to have just guess out of the blue that Gina had Graham's heart and crushed it.

^I disagree with that last part. After all she knows the curse was real, and in "The Queen of Hearts" she understood about the whole heart taking thing. You'd think she'd remember how Graham kept going on about his heart and how he needed to find it and how that was the same day that he ended up dying.

You're also forgetting that Emma is a) completely ignorant of magic, even now and b) didn't know that Regina officially had Graham's heart and killed him by crushing it.

Graham said he was looking for his heart. Emma put her hand on his chest and felt it beating. Graham was also saying a lot of crazy stuff, and wandered off into the woods and didn't know why. She had (and has) no logical reason to believe that Graham's heart was, literally, in Regina's hands.

yes i want emma to kick reginas butt

I think she knows but she can't do nothing/she doesn't care maybe? It's all up to the writers.....

There should have been a confrontation about Graham at some point. Instead, it was like the writers chose to forget about or ignore what happened to him once they'd determined that they'd redeem Regina. I actually think her redemption arc would have been even better if she did show genuine, specific remorse for something at some point.