Harry Potter vs Twilight Article: Old twilight fan writes about harry potter

25

Old twilight fan writes about harry potter

posted by nati30

This article was actually wriiten par an ex-twilighter(iloveyoudarling), not me, and i dont like the way she wrote it, cuz it is kinda rude, but i posté it so that maybe some twilighters here could consider giving harry potter a chance because the article proves that even though toi l’amour twilight there COULD be a better book out there:
Dear Twilight fans,

I was toi one day. Addicted to Twilight and couldnt ever stop lire it even if i had already read it 4 times. But trust me on this one will you. READ ANOTHER BOOOK!!! AFTER toi DO THAT TWILIGHT WILL SEEM LIKE A STUPID ROMANCE STORY.

After I had read Twilight saga about 8 times i read Harry Potter.

And all i can say is whoa!!

1. harry potter has a plot line that has never been used before.
2. twilight was a very easy read. simple sentences. i could write it
3. harry potter uses some imagination.
4. if edward wasnt sexy, everyone would be creeped out par him
5. harry potter>twilight

HARRY POTTER;
The most well thought out livres toi could ever read. There are SEVEN and each one is just as good as the one before. They go together perfectly. J.K. Rowling is a women that has a huge imagination and is tremendously creative. Okay Just Think About It. She wrote Harry Potter without any help. And everythingis made up. Try écriture a story like that. How many copies would toi sell? 100? 1000? Well she sold 11 million copies the first jour the last book came out? Could an average person do that? I dont think so.

TWILIGHT;
Wow. I'm pretty sure it's mostly smitten teenage girls who think Twilight is better. The écriture is low grade, the plot is simple and Bella as the main character doesn't compare to Harry as a main character. She's so flippin supid. And the way it ended, omg, not even a fight. Anyways, toi can't compare four livres about a sappy weak teenager in l’amour with a vampire to a 7 novel masterpiece with growing plots and characters. Harry Potter has so much plus depth. And it appeals to males and females alike.

simpleplan, graystone and 23 others like this

stickymonkey i don't know the person who wrote this, but if i did i'd go and send them flowers right this minute!

ilovecreed13 so would i

Mrs-Grint So would I and chocolate and cake.....and S. Meyers HEAD!!

Bookaholics I don't mean to be rude, and I do agree with you, but some of this is rather inaccurate. Harry Potter has a plot that's never been used before? Actually, the basic plot is a relatively standard one for modern fantasy. I don't mean to say it's bad, it's a plot that gets used a lot because it's a good one, but it's not exactly original. Twilight only appeals to sappy teenage girls? That's quite an assumption. Yes, that's a large part of the fanbase, but there are adults who like Twilight, and some boys. And for the record, not ending with a fight is not nesecarily a bad thing. There are tons of good books that don't end with fights, even fantasy ones. And while it can work, ending with a fight is sometimes just a way out of writing a good ending. (The battle in HP was very good, though.) I don't mean to offend anyone, it's just some constructive criticism.

PirateNinja3815 I don't think it's rude, I think iloveyoudarling wrote is just true facts.

taisa I think i can relate to you(iloveyoudarling) in a way. I think if i had read twilight first, i would have love it and think nothing about harry potter. Sure after i read twilight i was like 'WHOA'..HOT!!..but even when i said those words Harry Potter was still number one in mind cos i read it first, and plus it was just the best series!! And even though i thought twilight was COOL i never touched it ever again. Dont know why! And that goes for the rest of the twilight saga! I read them and liked them but never read them again..(I still dont know why)And ive got the whole series stacked up my shelf, untouched. Unlike Harry Potter i read them over and over again.

Renesemee717 i TOTALLY agree with u, Bookaholics PirateNinja3815, this article is just opinions and, like Bookaholics said, not all true Mrs-Grint, i have "seen" u before and u said the s. meyer's head thing before some people can get very offended by that and think bad of u (which i am sure is not true) though i have 2 admit, i love twilight, but harry potter was good (i just love romance)

Bookaholics I actually agree with her opinion, but I think all articles should be critiqued based on the writing, not if you agree with them. Plus, I think HP fans are sometimes kind of unfair to Twilight.

haropuff95 "Harry Potter has a plot that's never been used before? Actually, the basic plot is a relatively standard one for modern fantasy. I don't mean to say it's bad, it's a plot that gets used a lot because it's a good one, but it's not exactly original." \ I'm sure you're reffering to the part where an orphanage boy who is said to have power to defeat the Greatest Dark Wizard of all time?excuse me,but I think she's reffering to the WHOLE plots & including the SUBPLOTS inside it.How many story have u read titled Harry Potter which has Trolls,Giants,Raging centaur,froglike face woman become a tyrants,half-Giant Game Keeper at a school,non-wizard called 'muggle' mocked as 'mudblood',three 17 years old drop out school to search for parts of an Evil Wizard's soul,a 13 years old managed to produce Patronus to fight 1oo Dementors at a time,something called Priori Incatetam,a 12 years old killed a giant snake which can kills with a single eye-glance?and the lists go on.. \ "but there are adults who like Twilight, and some boys" proves?especially the fanboys. \ "And for the record, not ending with a fight is not nesecarily a bad thing. There are tons of good books that don't end with fights, even fantasy ones. And while it can work, ending with a fight is sometimes just a way out of writing a good ending." yea,the Hp fight was awesome.Yea,Twilight has no ending fight. So,HP is more adventurous like some Twilight fans claim did not. and just u know,ending with a fight is a good way of writing because the main characters inside it fight & sacrifice everything for theirs' & beloved ones' future.Happiness can be obtained by hardworks.I'm sorry but whats the point of gathering all vampires clans around the world just to have a cosy talk about a baby girl.They could have just record their videos or statements to prove Nessie wasn't guilty.They are wasting the clans' past times. by the way,not trying to offend u too.You sound like a reasonable fan,its rare to find a Twilighters like u. :)

dobbyssocks Hello! I am afraid that i am going to have to question you (Renessnee717). You said that you love romance, does this mean that you dont believe there is romance in hp? and bookaholics- ins not the fact that twilight didn't end in a fight seance, its that SMeyers built up to this big fight... and i fell flat, while harrys followed thought goodbye for now

dobbyssocks sorry my T key is sticky it is and IT fell flat sorry about that thanks

AprilCandy42 This is the best article I have read so far *cries in happiness* A former Twilight fan could also agree with us This is so damn good, if I knew you I could have given you your favorite food (if possible, if not, can we try something else?)

TwiChara I love this person so much! She speaks EXACTLY what was on my mind! SERIOIUSLY! READ HARRY POTTER!!!!!!!!!!!!! It is SSSoooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much better the Twilight!

mina_sit i used to be a fan of twilight but only for 5 months then the obssesion was started to fading and i started to wondering "why the f*ck i like this shit? harry potter is way better". then i watched dracula(1992), i remind that vampires are not sparkle and when i saw the twilight thing for another point of view i realised how the mass media has almost f*cked up my mind... i am an ex-twilight fun just like iloveyoudarling and i agree with her. i recommand to people to start read also some classic literature

auteur photo shoots

added by goodtimes

Emma Watson as Renesmee

added by goodtimes

1

Ask a Death Eater!

added by KateKicksAss

Source: askadeatheater.tumblr.com

6

Harry Potter vs Twilight

added by zanhar1

8

AVPM

added by SnapeLovesLily

Scared?

added by frankthe2nd

Source: tumblr

The Deathly Hallows pt.2 official posters

added by BellaLovett

10

Harry Potter graph

added by youknowit101

1

Thumbs up

added by Gred_and_Forge

Source: Tumblr

10

:D

added by narniafreak12

Source: motivatedphotos.com

2

Daniel / Harry

added by crazychocolate

1

Harry Potter is the book of THE livres

added by Brysis

4

Logical Reasons:Harry Potter vs Twilight

posted by cinnominbubble

Logical reasons...
why Harry Potter v.s Twilight

*WARNING SPOILERS*

Hi! I'm Cinnominbubble and I have noticed the war between fandoms have been going on for a while with no clear outcome. There is a reason to this-We are stubborn. Twihards want to stick up for Stephanie Meyer, whilst Potterheads want to do the same for J. K. Rowling. But, I have noticed something. Many of our reasonings aren't exactly logical. I mean, not to be offensive, some of our strongest points are downright idiotic!(from both sides) I'd like to come up with some smarter points to help people see our side of the story, whatever...

1

7 Undeniable Facts as to Why HP beats Twilight

posted by zar_far11

Harry Potter beats Twilight. Of course. But I really don't like it when HP fans use opinion-ated "facts" when saying WHY Harry Potter is the better movie series. So, I, who am a major Potterhead, put together 7 true, solid, hard, and undeniable facts about certain aspects of the two movie series to prove why Harry Potter is the ultimate series.
**I will only be discussing the movies**

1) Soundtrack

Listen to this wonderful and memorable theme song. As toi may have guessed, the theme song belogs to Harry Potter : link

Now listen to this: link
It's pretty, but it doesn't find a special place in...

lire the livres "Rant"

posted by yemi_hikari

Everyone knows Rowling and Meyer's stance on fanfiction and the fact both writers have donné a thumbs up of sorts. However, there is something I don't think either one of them would of approve of and it involves those Reading the Books a lot of people are supposedly writing. I say supposedly écriture because copying from another persons work is not écriture unless toi are quoting under fair use. And boy... every single lire the livres I've come across is not in fair use and constitutes plagiarism. I know how to write one that doesn't constitute plagiarism, but I'll save that until the end.

One...

4

From Twihard to Potterhead

posted by RonGetYourWand

As toi can tell from my username, I am a huge Harry Potter fan. However, I wasn’t always. I used to be a Twihard (a twilight obsessed fan-girl). In fact I was one during the early stages of puberty, which is the age where most Twitards fall into the ‘romantic’ trap.

Here’s my story about how I went from ‘Twihard’ to ‘Indifferent’ to ‘Potterhead’:

I first read Twilight as a recommendation from a fellow member of the Teen Advisory Board of my library. I finished that book quickly and moved onto the next. The bibliothèque didn’t have Eclipse so I read it ‘Twilight, New Moon, Breaking...

2

My Feelings Towards Bella cygne

posted by alexisn10

Believe it ou not, I do not hate Twilight. The plot is fair, internesting setting, a lot of the characters are good, and not to mention the brilliant fight scenes! The soundtracks are lovely as well as the actors/actresses. Overall, I would give the entire series a C+. I would give it a higher grade if it wasn't for the poor writing, rambling, and somewhat extreme fans. But what's really the anchor of that sinking ship is the books' protagonist and narrator...

Bella Swan.

Of course there's a main character in almost every book I read that I really do not like. For example: in Hunger Games, it's...

Why do toi think Twilight is a good book?

posted by krazyknoxy

I don't want to hear about Harry Potter ou any other book right now. I'm not setting this up for a débats about which is better. I just want to know seriously and honestly why toi Twilight fans enjoy lire Twilight. I want to see an actual reason that Twilight is a good book.
If toi don't like Twilight, I don't want to hear toi saying anything bad about it. I just want to know why people like it. Because all the debate's I've seen have no actual reasons. They have HP fans and Twihards going on about which book is better, but not why they like it.
I do actually want respectful débats though. I want to discuss the reasons toi give, but nicely.
If toi can't be respectful of each other's opinions then just don't comment.
And I'm not trying to hate on Twilight, but if I disagree with toi I will débats with you.
I don't know if there are other debate's about this, so I'm sorry if there are, but I didn't look.
I'm just rambling now so let's get onto it!

9

Which is really great literature?

posted by SuperSnuffles13

I thought of a very wonderful quote. I'm not sure where it came from. I might have read it somewhere before. Maybe it is many citations brought together. Maybe it is entirely of my own creation. I don't know. Anyways, I find it to be very beautiful and thought-provoking...

"Twilight is a children's book poorly disguised as great literature. Harry Potter is great literature poorly disguised as a children's book."

I doubt I wrote it. I'm not capable of coming up with something so witty and beautiful as that.

Allow me to explain what it means. It means that Twilight makes people think it is great literature...

4

Because My Taste In livres Is Just That Awesome

posted by LinaHarrow

Because My Taste In livres Is Just That Awesome

It's easy to point out the negatives in the things we don't like. Likewise, it's also easy to point out the positives in those things which we love. Difficult, it is, to accept the positives in that which we hate, and the negatives in that which we enjoy. Today, I would like to point out to toi solely the positives. And it's a good thing I like both things that I intend to praise because otherwise I might find this a difficult endevour to pursue.

In short, I'm gonna tell toi what's good about both HP and Twi. These might seem a bit repetitive to...