répondre à cette question

Le Monde de Narnia Question

First question: What does Aslan mean? (read description)

I know in several books, Aslan is known for saying: "No one can know what WOULD HAVE happened."
Yeah, okay, I got that, I respect that. But...
In the Magician's Nephew, Aslan tells Digory what would have happened if he had taken the fruit for himself.
This totally threw me off. Please help me!
 narnian_girl posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Le Monde de Narnia  meilleure réponse

Dearheart said:
Hmmm...that is a good question. I'm not sure if there is a definite answer to it, but this is how I personally see it.

No one is ever told what would have happened, and no one is told any story but their own. That's a given. HOWEVER, if toi think about it, Aslan wasn't so much telling Digory what would have happened as much as He was explaining how the fruit works. How toi can "find your heart's desire, and find despair" (in other words, "Be careful what toi wish for!") He told Digory what would have happened because it was necessary for him to understand and learn from it.

But in other instances, like Aravis wondering about the servant girl (in HHB), ou Lucy wondering about what might have happened had she gone to Aslan at once and left her siblings behind (in PC), it wasn't so important. Whether she knew ou didn't know wouldn't matter ou make things any better.

There are also two other factors to keep in mind: One, Aslan isn't a tame Lion. *wink* Two, Aslan is a wonderful but fictional "supposal" of Jésus created par a wonderful but imperfect human being named C. S. Lewis, who probably didn't obsess over his livres nearly as much as us Narniacs do. :P There's bound to be a few mistakes ou plot hiccups here and there.

That's my theory, anyway. Hope it helped! :-)
select as best answer
 Hmmm...that is a good question. I'm not sure if there is a definite answer to it, but this is how I personally see it. No one is ever told what would have happened, and no one is told any story but their own. That's a given. HOWEVER, if toi think about it, Aslan wasn't so much telling Digory what would have happened as much as He was [i]explaining[/i] how the fruit works. How toi can "find your heart's desire, and find despair" (in other words, "Be careful what toi wish for!") He told Digory what would have happened because [u]it was necessary for him to understand and learn from it.[/u] But in other instances, like Aravis wondering about the servant girl (in HHB), ou Lucy wondering about what might have happened had she gone to Aslan at once and left her siblings behind (in PC), it wasn't so important. Whether she knew ou didn't know wouldn't matter ou make things any better. There are also two other factors to keep in mind: One, Aslan isn't a tame Lion. *wink* Two, Aslan is a wonderful but fictional "supposal" of Jésus created par a wonderful but imperfect human being named C. S. Lewis, who probably didn't obsess over his livres nearly as much as us Narniacs do. :P There's bound to be a few mistakes ou plot hiccups here and there. That's my theory, anyway. Hope it helped! :-)
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Nice ideas :)
Stevey711 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
thanks dearhear! :D
narnian_girl posted il y a plus d’un an
*
thats the perfect answer!! MDR
LoverOfBeavers posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Réponses

Katia654321 said:
The word Aslan means Lion in Turkish.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Excuse me, but would it hurt to read the description BEFORE answering? Because obviously toi didn't.
narnian_girl posted il y a plus d’un an
Free_Spirit said:
I think that aslan would have told Diggory because it was sort of a warning not telling what would have happened. Because if aslan didn't tell him he would have eaten it but he wouldn't have known the consequences. In other cases there was two endings. Like if lucy had come early there were two outcomes but both sort of ended well.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
skandalop said:
"Great Lion"
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
uh... toi didn't read the description did you? tsk tsk.
narnian_girl posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »