remained one of its most lost (at least on Western shores) until 2016, when it finally received a US theatrical release after twenty-five years. Barred from much of the English-speaking world due to content concerns, watching the film makes it clear that it certainly isn’t aimed at children but for reasons quite apart from those that the distributors were worried about.
is a film about the sadness and sweetness of growing older and leaving your childhood by the wayside. Ghibli’s younger audience may appreciate its momentary pleasures, but it is the adults who will tear up at the bittersweet beauty of youthful reminisces.
It’s a film that chooses to play gently on the heart, whereas director Isao Takahata’s previous 1988 offering
made a far more brutal emotional attack. It’s a sharp left turn from one of Ghibli’s most acclaimed animators—second only in renown to the great Hayao Miyazaki—and one handled with grace. He saw the opportunity for the story in a manga series chronicling the disconnected misadventures of an 11-year-old girl named Taeko, but despite the appeal in these charming vignettes, it wasn’t until he pictured them as memories that he found his emotional through line.
And so, the film was split into two parts that interweave: one observes brief chapters in young Taeko’s life; the other watches a single movement in the life of her 27-year-old self as she travels from her city home to the country, eager to help with the farm work she’s always felt drawn to. Traveling on the train brings her mind back to her childhood in ways that prove both pleasant and painful but never too dramatic. This is a quiet film, and its attempts to make itself unassuming ensure that it sticks with you all the more.
With lengthy scenes in car interiors, outside in the expanse of nature and inside the walls of a school building, many minds will wander to one question: why was this animated? One key draw to the format is that animation can allow us to see things we never thought possible, and Ghibli has always capitalized on its fantastical benefits—particularly with Miyazaki’s magical beasts.
has none of that, yet it does understand something else about animation; drawn images have an expressive capacity that cannot be recreated in live action. There’s an ability to isolate certain colors, images, textures, and facial movements to draw our attention to them and tell us that this is the thing in the scene that matters most. The modern day sequences are standardly—if beautifully—drawn, but it’s in the flashbacks that the animation style of
feels most necessary. The edges of the frame have faded into white, like an old worn photograph. These memories of Taeko’s life do not follow one straight path; they are flashes from here and there. There’s an exploration of her first crush that is quickly dropped, not because of lazy storytelling, but because our heroine’s mind has wandered elsewhere. These are snapshots, and while her past may not be as crisp as her present, there are small details that remain as strong as if they had happened only yesterday.
It’s because of this patchwork quality that
often loosens its grip. You will find certain vignettes less compelling than others, and that will likely differ greatly from person to person, depending on what elements of your own childhood resonates the strongest through time. But even when your interest wavers, it’s ready to be roped back in by the next gorgeously realized detail. I myself was very taken by a scene that observes young Taeko’s excitement as she sees her first ever fresh pineapple. The whole family gathers (after a lengthy period of trying to work out how to cut it open) and prepares to take their first bite. But the moment’s ecstasy gives way quickly to deafening silence when each one in turn is struck by the disappointment of the less-than-ripe pineapple’s unpleasant taste. That silence is held for longer than you might expect, and we watch as Taeko’s family renounces the fruit. Only she is left, defiant and determined to remain in denial. The disappointment stings too badly. Her insistently optimistic innocence rings through loud and true.
works so well because Taeko isn’t a character we often see on screen. As an adult, she works in a bustling city and is significantly alone. Her boss is surprised at the joy on her face at the prospect of escaping to farming country. Often, a story like this would contrast childhood innocence with a hardened, world-weary, grown-up but older Taeko who retains the sweetness of her younger self. She is a quiet, kind woman, attracted to simply joys and the serenity of nature. In short, she is very pleasant company for two hours. We, as an audience, are happy to share in her stories and reflect on our own.
This really is a lovely little movie that improves each time I watch it. However, the adult stuff is less compelling to me than the flashbacks, which are adorable. I also love the pineapple scene.
I’ve never seen this film, probably for obvious reasons, but I really hope I can sometime. From your review it sounds really good and very unique. I wish studios in the US would make more adult focused animation. Adult like, what the movie appears to be, not adult like Sausage Fest.
Also, on a completely unrelated note, for some reason this review really made me want fresh pineapple, so I went out and bought one this afternoon. :p
This was a really good slice of life movie! Saw it from borrowing my friend’s copy since she and I are huge Daisy Ridley fans and man I kinda liked Ridley’s VAing in this! The only thing I found weird with this movie was a little bit of how close to home it felt for me personally being a girl and what they talked about (again just a personal thing for me alone), but I don’t hate it by any means!! Loved the animation style as well and contrasting past to present time! I’m glad I saw it 🙂
Why does the writer of this article not explicitely explain why distributers (ignorantly) hesitated to bring out this movie in the west?
The readers have the right to know there is anecdotal reference to the girls’ first period and the awkward way the young boys interact with the girls about it. http://www.iamag.co/features/itsart/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Only-Yesterday-6.jpg
Different writers chose to focus on different things but thank you for bringing that issue up in the comments section
Daily Debate: What Was (or is) the Best Decade for Animation?
Steven Universe Season 5 Premiere Trailer Released Online
Daily Debate: What animated movie should never get a prequel/sequel?
Studio Ghibli Countdown: ‘When Marnie Was There’
[DVD REVIEW] ‘Tangled: Before Ever After’ is Knotted Beginning for Promising Series
Studio Ghibli Countdown: ‘The Tale of Princess Kaguya’