Pretty Little Liars Recap: Can the Girls Trust a Newcomer Close to Mona? 

More Food More Pets More Red Carpet More TV Watch More Unfiltered More Country

How Bruce Jenner\'s Kids – and Kanye! – Reacted to His Transition News

David Beckham on His Kids: \'I\'m Literally an Uber Driver Now\' (VIDEO)

Cover Story: Inside Bruce Jenner\'s Emotional Journey

First Look – Six Packs and Hip Thrusts Included!

Bobbi Kristina and \'Husband\' Nick Gordon Were Never Married

Were Drugs Involved with Bobbi Kristina Brown\'s Near-Drowning?

William, Kate and George Enjoy the Sun and Surf in Mustique

Kevin Costner on Bobbi Kristina Brown: \'I Can\'t Imagine\' What Her Family Is Going Through

Prince Charles Had to Be \'Coaxed\' to His Wedding to Diana, Says Book

Robin Williams\'s Widow and Children Battle over His Estate

Recap: Can the Girls Trust a Newcomer Close to Mona?

From left: Hanna (Ashley Benson), Spencer (Troian Bellisario), Emily (Shay Mitchell) and Aria (Lucy Hale)

There\'s a new girl in Rosewood, and she could hold the key to unlocking Mona\'s (Janel Parrish) secrets.

Or, she could just be another A suspect. We have trust issues, okay?

Here\'s what happened on Tuesday night\'s episode of

• The Brew\'s chef Talia (Miranda Rae Mayo) totally iced out Emily (Shay Mitchell) after last week\'s kiss. But after lots of longing looks and one

intimate apron tying, they ended the episode with another steamy smooch.

• Lesli (Elizabeth McLaughlin), the ginger version of nerdy Mona suddenly appears, saying she\'s been BFFs with the deceased since they met at her grandmother\'s house and is in Rosewood to help out her mom. So far, all she does is pour Mrs. Vanderwaal\'s tea and cast suspicion on Mike (Cody Christian), who she claims she heard yell at Mona to hang up as they were chatting on the phone the day she died. Which brings us to ...

• ... Mike. We thought he was over his teen delinquency, but he\'s been secretly visiting Ali (Sasha Pieterse) in jail, as Spencer (Troian Bellisario) learns after rummaging through her lawyer mom\'s conveniently placed briefcase. Aria (Lucy Hale) follows him one night as he drives to a creepy bridge in a creepy forest to a creepy baggie of gummy bears for someone, and he confronts her but refuses to explain himself. "No one is giving me orders anymore," he yells. But who used to control poor Mike: Mona ... or Ali?

• Hanna (Ashley Benson) finds a recording of Bethany Young hidden in the spine of Mona\'s Edgar Allen Poe book (#JustNormalTeenageThings). On the tape, she screams at a Radley psychiatrist about an unknown enemy whom the Liars assume is Ali: "She\'s a bitch, she\'s an evil bitch. ... It\'s either me or her. ... She\'s not the only one who can make plans."

• Detective Holbrook (Sean Faris) is back, and he Hulks out at the police department after learning he\'s been suspended. Turns out, he was dealing with Internal Affairs the whole time he was gone – and not acting as Ali\'s puppet. He drunkenly assaults Hanna on the side of the road, but you

our girl put him in his place. "You don\'t get to play the victim here," she says after hitting him. "You\'re the grown-up police officer. She\'s just a girl."

• Spencer and barn boy Johnny (Will Bradley) are flirting up a storm, bonding over the Epic of Gilgamesh (seriously, she needs to go to college if only to become a classics major) and his weird installation art about, you guessed it, secrets. Where is Toby (Keegan Allen) and why is he not trying to solve their relationship problems so Spencer is distracted by his six-pack and forgets about this hipster.

• "I thought about it in the tub for so long my fingers started to look like pierogis." – Hanna, forever using her hefty similes

• "You have to keep your future properly aligned." – Veronica Hastings

• "Then I\'ll go to the chiropractor." – Spencer

• "This whole town is strung together by whispers." – Johnny

• What is Mike hiding, and what kind of woodland creature is he feeding gummy bears to in the scary forest?

• If Holbrook wasn\'t doing Ali\'s dirty work over the past few weeks, who was?

• Can we trust Lesli, Mona\'s mystery family friend?

• Are Emily and Talia going to make it Facebook official?

• Mike. Yeah, he\'s grieving, but he\'s acting even shadier than normal – and this is a guy who used to skip lacrosse practice to break and enter. Why won\'t he tell Aria about his visits to Ali? By now, he should know that his sister is basically Rosewood\'s Nancy Drew.

of Mona\'s? Yeah, right. Sure, they had their ups and downs – trying to blackmail and murder your BFF can really put the brakes on a friendship – but wouldn\'t Mona have at least mentioned Lesli is they were close enough to spend Thanksgiving together? And she was quick to plant the seed that Mike and Mona had relationship problems. Smells like deflection to us.

Just Broke a 1,000-Year-Old Viking Strongman Record (VIDEO)

Aurora Theater Shooting: Juror Dismissed in James Holmes Trial After Tearing Her Hair Out

Meryl Streep Do? See the Star Hone Her New Skill – Playing Guitar

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.

A Mini Cake Dedicated to Taylor Swift\'s \'Blank Space\' Video

Ryan Gosling, Plus Prince Harry, Henry Cavill & More!

31 Weeks and Counting: See Jill Dillard\'s Growing Baby Bump

Body After Baby: Star Moms Who Bounced Right Back

Camila Alves Blogs: See the Tractor Cake I Made for My Son\'s Birthday

Why Maksim Chmerkovskiy and Kirstie Alley Aren\'t Speaking

Chris Pratt Flashed Amy Poehler?! Hear His Take – And See Her Reaction

Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.