<33 but both

Like both though

I used to like her so much when she was a teenage

Deffo, she is an awesome teenager, I f*cking love her in 1-4, so interesting and admirable, she has values that you don't find frequently in a teenager and she is so funny! After S5 she is still great but kinda boring :(

But that was hard to choose :D

Both

Both <3

I feel like in seasons 3 & 4 she acted like "Adult Haley"- it was just weird though cause she was 17 and 18. Season 1 she acted more like a teen; she was still mature but was definitely more sarcastic and still a teen. But in the other high school seasons, she acted like an adult while still being a teenager. So in the later seasons it made more sense having Haley act really mature but with a funny sarcastic side, since she was actually an adult.

I almost always love Haley, but my favorite Haley seasons are 1,7, and 8.
Plus it felt like Haley was much more comfortable with herself and her life in seasons 6-9.