répondre à cette question

Once Upon A Time Question

Why is it that Hook and CS fans seem to hate Regina? And why do Regina and SQ fans seem to hate Hook?

I don't know if anyone here can answer this because I haven't seen it here as much as on tumblr and twitter.

I've just been under the impression that it's due to the ship war but then I've also seen Hook fans hate on Regina for non-ship related things.

Personally (though I hate CS) I really don't hate Hook. I didn't care for him getting most of the screentime but I don't hate him. I guess I just don't see where this Hook vs Regina fans thing comes from. Especially since the two characters never seemed to have an issue with each other.
 Why is it that Hook and CS fans seem to hate Regina? And why do Regina and SQ fans seem to hate Hook?
*
Some fans just like to create meaningless wars between characters for no logical reason.
SilentForce posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Guess this just goes hand in hand with me not seeing the point in creating drama where there is none. Like no wonder ya'll are angry all the time; if toi don't have anything to complain about, ya'll create something!
zanhar1 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
*Sends in zanhar74 just to be an anushole*
zanhar1 posted il y a plus d’un an
 zanhar1 posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Once Upon A Time Réponses

NCISLuverjk93 said:
This doesn't really answer your question but,

I'm a Hook/Captain cygne lover and I adore Regina! <3
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
xP It's all good. Due to tumblr it's just so refreshing to see a CS/Hook fan who loves Regina (or a Regina fan who likes CS/Hook).
zanhar1 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
I never understood people that dislike a character solely due to a dit character getting in the way of their ship, but it makes even less sense here because how is Regina in the way of Hook/Emma anyway? Lmao.
NCISLuverjk93 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Don't hate each other
csismyotp posted il y a plus d’un an
lililc said:
four words: Die for our ship ,the most awful thing in all fandoms
It can happen to they actually hate the charanter for no ship related but they normally just make excuses
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
I figured as much. Though I've always found it silly when people hated on a character for 'getting in the way of my ship'. I do hate ships for ruining my ship but never the characters involved (unless I hated him/her prior). I guess I also don't get it because Regina in no way is detrimental to CS (unless they are worried that A&E will go with SQ), if anything it is the SQ fans who should be butthurt. Oh well, no matter which side is doing the hating it's still silly IMO. I mean Hook and Gina aren't really that different.
zanhar1 posted il y a plus d’un an
banditsns1391 said:
I don't get it. Personally, I l’amour Hook and CS. I don't hate Regina; I actually really like her. Initially though, I didn't trust Hook and I didn't like Regina (hey, she was the Evil Queen who was basically holding a whole town hostage). I think all three (Emma, Hook, and Regina) have grown so much since the beginning and hating on them is unnecessary. Also I agree that the characters don't seem to hate each other. Sure they don't completely trust each other but they probably understand each other; especially since other people don't trust them for their pasts. Oddly that makes me wonder why people don't ship them. Evil Hook, anyone?
I'm sure in some cases it does boil down to ship wars. I mostly come across hate for Hook (especially on Tumblr; I haven't been on here for a long time). Mostly it's about Hook being manipulative and being such a horrible person ou something. The few things I've seen about Regina was basically about her being hypocritical ou selfish. I guess people will find any flaw to complain about ou exploit, but if the character had no flaws they'd say they were boring.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Hook Queen was my OTP at one point! The fact that CS put a block in the road to canon for it is one of the reasons I don't like it to be honest lol. That a dit the two characters are so similar I don't get it. That kind of stuff is why I avoided tumblr for a while. Came back in hopes that it died down but nah. I've been seeing a lot of 'Hook is abusive and sexist' and a lot of 'Regina is selfish and a rapist'. Like what?
zanhar1 posted il y a plus d’un an
anaswill said:
Personally I am a big fan of Regina and of SQ, and I don't like Hook ou CS at all, but for me, how I feel about Hook has nothing to do with SQ. I've never had a problem with multishipping ou with separating my feelings for a couple with my feelings for a character, so I feel comfortable saying that I don't think SQ ou Regina has anything to do with how I feel about CS/Hook.

Having a dit that, I've totally seen what you're talking about happen in the fandoms, and I think part of what's responsible for that is a feeling of frustration on the shippers part -- if Hook wasn't there SQ would be plus likely to happen -- if Regina wasn't there the SQ fandom wouldn't exist and would stop pressing for SQ to happen. There is also a feeling of competitiveness, I think, and pettiness, and maybe a little entitlement too. Oh and also this type of situation happens a lot on Tumblr -- one Regina fan goes on anon and starts hating on Hook fans, then the Hook fans (understandably) get pissed at them and start bashing Regina, Regina fans get upset, and so on and so forth.. And the fact that Hook and Regina are the two most populaire characters on the show, and naturally get the most screentime, may contribute to it. When Hook gets most of it in one episode the Regina fans blame him for Regina barely getting any, and vice versa.

Sorry if this doesn't make much sense, I'm very tired right now lol.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
It makes perfect sense. I'm in the same bateau as toi as far as what I ship and don't ship. However I'm mostly okay with Hook. I just wish they'd take that god-forsaken anon feature away; people abuse it way too much. I'm willing to bet that some of the anons aren't even real Regina/Hook fans they just pretend to be so they can start plus fights. "And the fact that Hook and Regina are the two most populaire characters on the show, and naturally get the most screentime, may contribute to it. When Hook gets most of it in one episode the Regina fans blame him for Regina barely getting any, and vice versa." This is a very good point, never though of that one.
zanhar1 posted il y a plus d’un an
KataraLover said:
I think there are two reasons for this.

1.Regina and Hook are usually making one-liners at each other to insult the other. Unfortunately, a bunch of overly emotional fans get butthurt about things like this. It's similar to all the Cora fans being butthurt over Snow White killing Cora and the Cruella fans being butthurt over Emma killing Cruella. While their putdowns aren't nearly as extreme as killing, it does get on fans nerves to see a character they l’amour being put down par another character a lot.

2.Part of the fault is also the fans one group that annoy the other. I remember I time where I wanted to hate on both characters because their fans drove me crazy and hated on other characters that I loved constantly just to praise them. Hard to believe, since Regina is my favori character now. I mean, I do see a lot of things that do bug fans on here. It's like how Regina fans loved that Emma became the Dark One to save Regina, but hated that she embraced the darkness to save Hook. That seems pretty hypocritical if toi ask me. I'm not the biggest fan of Captain Swan, but it makes sense that, that's what made Emma embrace the darkness. Rumple's son is what made him become what he is and Nimue wanting to be with Merlin forever is what made her become the first Dark One. Both did it for their loved ones, but their own personal greed and pain also caused them to become evil.

Emma does become a villain, despite what some may think. She tried to justify her actions for being in the name of good and that she'd make up for it. Sound familiar? Rumple a dit he was doing all he did for his son and would make up for everything bad he had done. Emma was willing to take the risk that Merida could kill Belle if Rumple didn't become a hero and stop her, risk Rumple being turned to dust if he's not the one meant to take the sword from the stone, and was planning to kill Zelena. Oh yeah, that doesn't sound evil at all! She just realized her mistakes LONG before Rumple did and before she was too far in embracing her darkness. Unlike other Dark Ones, Emma wanted to get rid of her power as the Dark One, so she needed a strong way of embracing her. What better way than through a loved one? I also, don't even think Captain cygne even a volé, étole all that much from the other characters in the Dark cygne half, even when I was a HARDCORE hater of that ship.

Plus with a lot of fans of cygne Queen hating on Captain Swan, that makes them retaliate. They want Hook killed off so cygne Queen can happen, especially since Robin is dead. However, cygne Queen fans have to have it rubbed in their face par the Captain cygne fans that the creators of Once Upon A Time a dit back when season 2 was airing that cygne Queen WASN'T going to happen. So they're attacking them for not shipping Captain cygne when it's canon. Plus there is some that are likely homophobic, so that's definitely a factor in the cygne Queen hate.
select as best answer
 I think there are two reasons for this. 1.Regina and Hook are usually making one-liners at each other to insult the other. Unfortunately, a bunch of overly emotional fans get butthurt about things like this. It's similar to all the Cora fans being butthurt over Snow White killing Cora and the Cruella fans being butthurt over Emma killing Cruella. While their putdowns aren't nearly as extreme as killing, it does get on fans nerves to see a character they l’amour being put down par another character a lot. 2.Part of the fault is also the fans one group that annoy the other. I remember I time where I wanted to hate on both characters because their fans drove me crazy and hated on other characters that I loved constantly just to praise them. Hard to believe, since Regina is my favori character now. I mean, I do see a lot of things that do bug fans on here. It's like how Regina fans loved that Emma became the Dark One to save Regina, but hated that she embraced the darkness to save Hook. That seems pretty hypocritical if toi ask me. I'm not the biggest fan of Captain Swan, but it makes sense that, that's what made Emma embrace the darkness. Rumple's son is what made him become what he is and Nimue wanting to be with Merlin forever is what made her become the first Dark One. Both did it for their loved ones, but their own personal greed and pain also caused them to become evil. Emma does become a villain, despite what some may think. She tried to justify her actions for being in the name of good and that she'd make up for it. Sound familiar? Rumple a dit he was doing all he did for his son and would make up for everything bad he had done. Emma was willing to take the risk that Merida could kill Belle if Rumple didn't become a hero and stop her, risk Rumple being turned to dust if he's not the one meant to take the sword from the stone, and was planning to kill Zelena. Oh yeah, that doesn't sound evil at all! She just realized her mistakes LONG before Rumple did and before she was too far in embracing her darkness. Unlike other Dark Ones, Emma wanted to get rid of her power as the Dark One, so she needed a strong way of embracing her. What better way than through a loved one? I also, don't even think Captain cygne even a volé, étole all that much from the other characters in the Dark cygne half, even when I was a HARDCORE hater of that ship. Plus with a lot of fans of cygne Queen hating on Captain Swan, that makes them retaliate. They want Hook killed off so cygne Queen can happen, especially since Robin is dead. However, cygne Queen fans have to have it rubbed in their face par the Captain cygne fans that the creators of Once Upon A Time a dit back when season 2 was airing that cygne Queen WASN'T going to happen. So they're attacking them for not shipping Captain cygne when it's canon. Plus there is some that are likely homophobic, so that's definitely a factor in the cygne Queen hate.
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Regina fans also seem to hate Hook for "stealing attention" away from their favori character when really she didn’t get shafted during the Dark cygne story line. I think all of the characters got the right amount of screen time they needed for every story arc they were in. If anything, the character who got shafted during the Dark cygne was Zelena. If we didn’t have Hook becoming the Dark One and dying we wouldn’t have gotten Regina settling her parents unfinished business, becoming close with her sister, and the AWESOME new storyline of the Evil Queen being back! Besides, if toi l’amour a show, shouldn’t toi be invested in plus than just one ou two characters? The spin-off failed because the only interesting characters were the villains and the good guys were both annoying and as interesting as watching paint dry. Once Upon A Time has a lot of great characters that I am invested in and can hold me attention, even if Regina doesn’t get a lot of scenes. It’s not like during the La Reine des Neiges story line where the only main characters to get any real attention were Emma and Rumple (Mainly him being an ass) and the rest of the attention was hogged par Ingrid and the La Reine des Neiges characters. So it’s jealousy of the other characters stealing scenes from other characters that gets on their nerves. This season that was definitely the case with Regina vs Hook. Jealously and being green with envy isn’t very fun, just as Zelena!
KataraLover posted il y a plus d’un an
*
I guess with #1 I've always seen their banter as friendly banter; the same way she insults Emma. Legit I think Regina insulting people is her way of montrer affection. Heaven knows I bother the absolute hell out of my Friends for lols. I can totally see #2 being an issue I still resent Graham a bit because his fans drove me batshit. Not gonna lie I only hated her embracing he dark JUST for Hook because I feel like it diminished the potential the arc had. As for number 3 this one always bugged me; ship wars at their finest. Honestly I think that this one is worse than Zutara vs Kataang.I also admit to resenting Hook for shafting Regina; but that's also because I feel like Snow & Charming and Henry got majorly shafted as well. Henry probably had it the worst.
zanhar1 posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »