I decided to write this article because I have seen many commentaires lately that kind of bother me.
There are several picks in which this has come up, but the last one I have seen, and the reason why I am écriture this is the question: ¿Have toi completely changed your attitude towards a character after reading/watching their past stories?
(or something along those lines) link
It is a really interesting question, and what really caught my attention were the answers, the comments, especially since it wasn't the first time that I am lire commentaires like those.
The thing is that in that pick, James Potter is "winning". In other words, a lot of people say that after seeing what Harry saw on the Pensive (James and his Friends bullying Snape) they have now (and I quote) "lost all respect for him"
Another populaire answer is that after seeing Snape's back story they now "think of him as a hero"
I can't help but notice that those réponses are a bit biased. I don't mean this in a bad way I am just trying to understand why when James does it, he is HORRIBLE, but with Snape all is forgiven.
I mean their stories are identical
, the only difference is that we learn about them backwards. With Snape FIRST we learn he is a bully and LATER we learn he is a Hero. While with James FIRST we learn he is a hero while LATER we learn he used to be a bully.
But in all honesty, can lire about someone's past make toi change everything toi know about them so far? Is that fair? Has no one made mistakes? Of course these characters have made mistakes, that's what makes them so REAL, but that doesn't mean they are bad, ou that we can't respect them. They all have made bad choices in the past, yes... But so? WE ALL HAVE. No one here can say that haven't made any mistakes in their past, ou that they don't continue making mistakes on a DAILY BASIS. The important thing and what really counts is seeing how those characters were able to turn it around, were able to mature, to change, to make up for their mistakes. THAT is what really counts because that is the most difficult thing to do. What I don't understand is why people are able to do that for Snape but not for James
Let's see: Snape
was a bully. Worse than James in my opinion, because he used his position of power to bully those who are in a lower position, his students. As a grown man he bullied kids, and pretty bad. He wasn't nice anyone who wasn't Slytherin, and he was specifically mean to those who needed a bit plus time to learn like Neville. Yes, he was a bully... He was once a follower of Voldemort, he loved the dark arts and all of that. BUT
he was able to love, he loved Lily and that saved him. His l’amour turned him into a hero because after seeing what Voldemort did to her he became Dumbledore's spy, he worked to bring Voldemort down and he GAVE HIS LIFE
for that cause, to protect Harry. He became a hero.
From the commentaires it is sûr, sans danger to assume that everyone agrees with me on that point, we are all able to overlook Snape's mistakes (which were many) and see him as a hero.
So my question is why can't people do that for James? Why are people suddenly saying they "lost all respect" for him just par learning that he made mistakes in the past? IT'S THE SAME STORY AS SNAPE. Let's go back again: James
and his Friends bullied Snape when they were young. They were teenagers, immature, stupid, and they bullied someone who was different from them. However, James changed. He fell in l’amour with Lily and she fell in l’amour with him because he changed. He matured, he joined the Order of the Phoenix in order to fight against Voldemort, to fight against a dark and unfair world. He GAVE HIS LIFE
for that mission, he gave his life trying to save his wife and his son, he gave his life because he LOVED them. That makes him a hero too.
ou are we able to overlook Snape's past mistakes but not James'?? Is that fair?
All I want to get out of this article is for people to try and think about it more. Try to look past how much they l’amour Snape's character, and see the big picture. "Harry Potter
" is about embracing past mistakes, and being a better person for them. That's what James did, that's what Snape did, that's what Dumbledore did, and that's what basically ALL the characters did. It's not fair to judge James for what he did when he was a kid and say toi "lost all respect for him" because HE WAS a hero too. And in my opinion NO story about anyone's past should change your opinion of who they were later, of who they are now, because mistakes don't define a person. We all make them.
I hope we can all see that, and stop all the James hate that is seriously unjustified...