I think that the only way to get it close to what the book portrayed is to make it rated R but lots of twilght fans are going to be unhappy with that rating, donné most are teens. If it is rated PG-13 then plus fans will be able to watch it but it will lose some of its scenes due to inappropriateness. I personally don't really care what they rate it as long as it's REALLY GOOD!
at first i wanted this film to be rated R like most of you. but now im leaning plus to the PG-13 side. it happened while i watching KalebNation's vid about the BD rating debate. his points on why its not a good idea for it to be rated R really got me rethinking my reasons why i had decided on it. and after awatching the vid Kaleb had won me over MDR :)