why in new moon did edward leave.he a dit he never would? and another thing MDR why did he push her into the wall. thet only made it worse. and also, bella should not be cheating on edward. jacob is cool but a homewrecker. i am a dude! and i even a dit

well he knew humans are "fragile" he could of been a little lighter but yeah the divisé, split seconde helped. if he had not of done thatshe would of been pain grillé

i think i will vote toi for best answer

well in my opinion... i know that iwas just saying jacob knows that she hasa bf. and also bella was about to Kiss him to. like i say." look but dont touch"

i agree with jleisten bella would always Kiss him. if she didnt want she wouldnt even let him try s’embrasser her

She did kind of cheat on him, on Eclipse she did Kiss back, but Edward was cool with it - as long as she's happy.

no i own all four and have read all four.and seen both the films when they first came out and still i know he did it to protect her but it was still a little harsh theway he left her.

Well, if toi have read the books, toi should know that it was written that Edward left her because he thought that it was dangerous for him and his family to be around Bella. He wanted her to live a normal human life. I do agree with toi that the way he left her was a little abrupt but he did it because he thought it was for her own good. I'll have to disagree with toi and your statement that Bella cheated with Jacob. Bella was on the edge of moving on with Jacob but she was undecisive. I wouldn't call her a 'cheater'. It's merely part and parcel of life. Some people rather leave those dark, painful memories and get on with their lives. I think it's perfectly reasonable.

i know what i am talking bout. i understand that but still. if she loved jacob then why did she pick eward i know she loves him plus but her world would bea little plus sûr, sans danger with him.

Erm. I really don't get what you're trying to say. "i know she loves him plus but her world would bea little plus sûr, sans danger with him." Ay, you're saying that Bella's world would be a little plus safer with Edward? I can't really tell what you're trying to say. O_O Never mind... Anyway... She picked Edward because she felt that 'she can't live without him'. It's plus than that but for me to write it all out, it's a little too long. When Edward left Bella in New Moon, he hoped that Bella would déplacer on with her nomal human life. He didn't know he was inflicting such pain on Bella. *Which I thought rather silly of him.* His intentions meant well, but it didn't go as smoothly as he thought it wold be. Well, personally... If I were Bella, I wouldn't have made the choice that she made. I don't get why toi a dit that Jacob is a homewrecker. His actions in Eclipse was the result for his l’amour and concern for Bella. He just didn't like the idea of Bella giving up her humanity just to be with her vampire lover. Jacob just wanted Bella to realize that she has other alternatives, besides living her life with Edward, which was true. Quoting from Eclipse: "I could see what he saw, and I knew that he was right. If the world was the sane place, it was supposed to be. Jacob and I would be happy. He was my soulmate in that world- would have been my soulmate still if his claim had not been overshadowed par something stronger, something so strong that it could not exist in a rational world," I wouldn't call Jacob a 'homewrecker'. I think his intentions were for Bella's own good as well.

no i own all four and have read all four and seen both films theday they came out and still i know he did it to protect her but it was still a little harsh the way heleft her