répondre à cette question

The Host Question

Have toi read the bonous chapter (Melanie's pov)?Did toi liked it?

Am i the only one who thinks is was quite...bad written? Don't get me wrong i am a huge fan of Stephenie and i realy do l’amour the way she writes but i have to be honest. It was boring ...and even though i have read "the host" 2 times already i don't think i am gonna read the extra chapter again.
 marthatsal posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

The Host Réponses

fanfangirlfan said:
i really liked it!! i think maybe the language may have been a little less extensive and intelligent because melanie has a different voice than wanda. i didnt even know there was a bonus chapter because i read the host so long ago, i have a copy that didnt even include the bonus chapter yet. when i read it i was just so happy that there was plus to the story! i realllly loved it. i didnt think it was boring but i kind of get what youre saying about the quality.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
helomusic said:
Me too, I didn't like it at all. It felt off and it was like it wasn't really Melanie, it felt another character. I've read the book a lot of times and it's one of my favourite, but it made me dislike Melanie.
If I'm going to re read the book, I won't read that extra chapter because it kind of doesn't fit the book at least for me.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
jos613 said:
I thought it went along with the book well, but it must have been written fast ou she was caught up with something else. i particularly like it except the couteau slashing part from melanie that could have been easily resolved from an explanation, so toi did see a diference from the book and this chapter but im happy she made it since was curious about that part of the story(mostly how Ian found out)
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
next question »