Who else thinks Evangeline Lilly would be the best Melanie?

I don't agree. She's older than Mel's age but I agree that she's a very good actress and a very beautiful woman.

I totally agree with you. Shes a good actress and she fits the description of Melanie really well.

i think she would make the perfect melanie! if only she was a little younger :(

Yeah, I l’amour LOST, so I get your point. And maybe she can play a younger girl, I don't know. She's almost perfect!

This is the first cast suggestion that I actually agree with. Evangeline Lilly looks like what I pictured Melanie to look like.

I l’amour Lost, but I don't like her even in it. I don't think she is beautiful enough for Mel when she doesn't make up. But you're right about her muscles, she is muscular like a man, not womanish. If she Makes Up, she can be a pretty lady.

Evangeline fans will kill me, but that's what i thought.

I think she would be a great Mel. If i'd have to choose any actress to play her, I would pic Evangeline.
She may be a little old, yes, but she seems so younger than she really is. And Sophia buisson, bush has almost Evangelline's age (just 3 years younger).
I think the biggest problem with her is that she is too short, but in that case is easier to deal with. I mean, they made Taylor seem taller than Robert.

sophia bush