répondre à cette question

Stephen King Question

Do toi think SK was right when he bashed Stephenie Meyer, ou were toi against it? Either way, would toi like to rejoindre this spot:

link
ou if toi think this is a bad spot, just tell me how to supprimer it because I'm already skeptical about making it...
*
There's no sense to versus them with each other. They're écriture style is utterly different, genre is utterly different (as no, SMeyer's livres can not seriously be called horror in its common means), King is far superior to Meyer in every aspect of literature and that's a fact of selling numbers and critics and likely in fan base numbers too, and not just a matter of opinion on whose écriture entertains toi personally. Deeply psychological, well-developed characters and creative, sometimes brilliant plots with vivid, coloutful and quality écriture VS. sparkling teen 'vampires' in high school, cliche plots, abused prose, focusing on how hot and beautiful the main character is and mary-sue characters? Seriously! No sense in versusing an award winning, professional auteur to some woman who just got lucky, while écriture like a teenage girl lacking also imagination. So yes, King was definately right and he has nothing to be jealous of.
bendaimmortal posted il y a plus d’un an
 sapherequeen posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Stephen King Réponses

Loky said:
I l’amour King's écriture since as 11yo I've read 'It' and it scared the hell out of me. What he a dit about Meyer just confirmed he's my Master. After lire some interview with that Pattinson guy it susprised me that he had the same opinion as me about the book - it's fat mormon mamma (that's only my part;P) écriture down her erotic fantasies and it's mostly just embarrassing to read. Beside that the language is poor (about 15 verbs and 10 adjectives over and over again), characters MarySue-ish (did she hear about character development?!) and the message simply dangerous for children's minds.
I really don't want to offend anybody par saying this but in my opinion Twilight is a book for bored miserable housewives and hormon-overwhelmed teenage girls. And Edward? Could he be plus of an abusive boyfriend? Srsl he makes me sick.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
From someone who reads both, your right now, not that I dislike either but SK is alot better. Twilight is also a book for Navy Engineering Girls who don't have the time to think about what they are lire <me. MDR
ChiffaniChan posted il y a plus d’un an
*
I meant on not now.
ChiffaniChan posted il y a plus d’un an
renrae said:
I think he was right. Stephenie Meyer's quality of écriture is, dare I say it, low. Most of the grammar is improper, and the characters are underdeveloped ou too perfect. But I won't rejoindre the spot because I don't want anything to do with SMeyer. I would supprimer it because there would probably be a very uneven fan number* but it's your decision.




*I know some people who got a little bit out of hand when the Stephen King thing happened, and most people would just say "Stephen King is a bad writer and he isn't popular, he took too long to write books, his livres are stupid because there is no Edward, etc.,
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
AgentCoop said:
As someone who loves SK and thinks Twilight is fairly ridiculous, I think he was just speaking the truth. He can write circles around her.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
drwyle said:
in my opinion, he was just saying what everyone else was thinking....(everyone that's not a screaming teenage girl that is...)
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
tuttleAC said:
He hit it out of the park with me when he mention another kids book series, Harry Potter, and says the difference between J.K. and Stephanie is that J.K actually has talent.

Regardless of what toi think of the story and characters toi have to admit that Twilights writting is very simplistic.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
breebree446 said:
I think if that's how SK feels then he should be able to express it. The only people who are probably bashing him are those overly crazed twilight fan girls. It's a book people, not the world.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
Nicoleandjames said:
of course he was right it needed to be a dit everybody else was to scared to say it but stephen was Rebelle enough to say it and i'm sure all those people who have to cover twilight are biting there tongues because they have to talk about that stupid shit
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
A million people a dit the same thing before him, and no one was scared to say it.
ChiffaniChan posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »