Nathan is a GREAT dad!! But Lucas would also be awesome :)

Nathan is a dad and he is fantastic

yep

Yeah I think Nathan .. Lucas is too moody

i'd say nathan is a pretty good dad, but I have to go with Lucas...i mean he did learn from the best didn't see(keith)

i picked lucas cos he's an awesome uncle to Jamie but i think nate's starting to be an awesome dad again. I think they'd both be good dad's (even tho nathan already is one)

i think luke would be the best dad because he had a great one in keith and hes really caring for jamie but nate is starting to get his act together and he is totally in love with jamie its obvious but luke is so better

yes Luke is a good uncle but i don't no if he could handle being a Father figure permanently doing everything not just the fun stuff... n Nathan is definitely picking up the pace.

i think lucas would be a great dad especially if ti was to peyton's child
nathan is a great dad though