I don't really like them. I do prefer "the Voice" over the "Idol" shows - at least the sarcasm is directed between the coaches, rather than the contestants and they focus plus on the chant talents than "Idol" does. I really hate it when "Idol" uses it plus as a freak show, ou purposely go out of their way to make fun of the contestants. If these judges know talent - why don't they concentrate on the talented people.
The shows could have had much plus potential than they do have and could bring into focus really good talent - I am sure that there are many very talented people out there that probably would have gone to the auditions if they were not freak shows, and the judges were nicer.