Harry Potter

répondre à cette question

Harry Potter Question

*SPOILER ALERT* Did anybody else have issues with the major differences in Dumbledore's death scene in HBP?

i'm sorry in advance if this is a duplicate.
i just mean, i think the movie made Harry look real bad. he just stood there and didn't try to do anything. meanwhile, in the book, Dumbledore was supposed to have paralyzed him and thrown the invisibility manteau over him so that there was NOTHING HE COULD DO! in the movie, it just seemed like Harry chickened out and didn't bother trying to stop what was happening.

What do toi think?
 PiiXiiE posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Harry Potter Réponses

volleyblue13 said:
I don't think that this made Harry look bad. It is basically the same thing. He feels helpless, because he promised Dumbledore that he wouldn't come out of hiding, and it makes him hate Snape because he thought that Snape was there to help him. The details may be different, but the main point is still the same. And Harry didn't "CHICKEN OUT". He was getting ready to do something, but Snape stopped him and made it look like he was going to take care of it. Also, until it happened, Harry had no clue that Dumbledore was going to die, because to him, and the rest of us, it seemed impossible.
 select as best answer
I don't think that this made Harry look bad. It is basically the same thing. He feels helpless, because he promised Dumbledore that he wouldn't come out of hiding, and it makes him hate Snape because he thought that Snape was there to help him. The details may be different, but the main point is still the same. And Harry didn't "CHICKEN OUT". He was getting ready to do something, but Snape stopped him and made it look like he was going to take care of it. Also, until it happened, Harry had no clue that Dumbledore was going to die, because to him, and the rest of us, it seemed impossible.
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
oh, i understand. i'm not saying he chickened out; just that the movie might have made it appear a litle like that. but i understand your point too.
PiiXiiE posted il y a plus d’un an
vampaholic said:
yeah i didnt like it but i try not to compare livres with the films cuz toi just see all the problems instead of enjoying the movie
 select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
yeah thats so true :)
volleyblue13 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
i thoroughly enjoyed the movie while i was still at the theatre, an then the plus i talked to other ppl the plus all these differences occurred to me... i blame the others! LoL but you're right.
PiiXiiE posted il y a plus d’un an
dylin1 said:
i totally hated the differences! and all those death eaters WEREN'T supposed to be there!
 select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
Actually, most of them WERE there... maybe not all but most
volleyblue13 posted il y a plus d’un an
*
Actually, no. Not in the book.
dylin1 posted il y a plus d’un an
SonicIsMine said:
I think it was so annoying! I mean, he's harry potter! He would never chicken out of anything and they make him ust stand there while his friend is being killed par monsters!!!
 select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
slytheringirl22 said:
I think that harry was plus like he was supposed to be in shock ou something. but i think that they TOTALLY messed up the movie in SOOOOOO many ways!!! i mean, don't get me wrong, I luvh the movie, but they skipped so many parts and changed so many things around that my mom got SOOOOOOO pissed when we came accueil that they didn't montrer the fighting scene and all. but yah......
 select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
*
i just suppose they'll have to rebuild the Burrow now, since Harry's supposed to live there suivant an and there's a wedding happening there and such...
PiiXiiE posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!