anyone els think its funny that lilys partronus is a doe and james is a stag???

LifesGoodx3 said:

It shows that they belong together...

posted il y a plus d’un an

agree with u:)

Hermione30 posted il y a plus d’un an

Yes

Thecharliejay posted il y a plus d’un an

LinaHarrow said:

No, Patronus's change remember? Lilly's could have changed because james was a cerf as an anamagous.

posted il y a plus d’un an

Think you're right. It be weird if it were mere coincidence.

JavaJoker posted il y a plus d’un an

good point....

disneygirl11 posted il y a plus d’un an

Hiding 2 comments... click to show.

I thought so too, LinaHarrow.

bri-marie posted il y a plus d’un an

HaleyDewit said:

It's kinda ironic,yeah :)

posted il y a plus d’un an

AmyPond23 said:

Yeah, Its quite cool!!!
Stranhe though!
JK Rowling mabey planned it, ou did it just flow natrually!

posted il y a plus d’un an

bessmarvin1 said:

I dnt noe.Nothing abt Lily's patronus is mentioned until the last book 2 montrer snape's l’amour for her

posted il y a plus d’un an

so??? its still funny!!!

NataliaLidia posted il y a plus d’un an

MDR

harrypotter-rox posted il y a plus d’un an

fanofh2o said:

I don't think Lily's partronus is a doe, well it doesn't say. but Snapes the one whos partronus is a doe...........

posted il y a plus d’un an

Actually, it does say. Harry says to Voldemort, "You never saw Snape cast a patronus, did you, Riddle? [...] Snape's patronus was a doe, the same as my mother's, because he loved her for nearly all of his life, from the time they were children." [pg 740]

bri-marie posted il y a plus d’un an

But still,only Harry mentions that

bessmarvin1 posted il y a plus d’un an

HecateA said:

I think Lilyalways sort-of liked James deep-down, like Ron and Hermione (but less obvious)

posted il y a plus d’un an

i dont know, he was horible as a child, not sayi ng i dont like him.

harrypotter-rox posted il y a plus d’un an

Icepool78 said:

James is a cerf because Lily is a doe. Lily made it clear that she had no interest whatsoever in James while they were at school, but James was always in l’amour with her and probably chose his Animagus form to be a cerf to reflect his love.

posted il y a plus d’un an

o, yeh

harrypotter-rox posted il y a plus d’un an