répondre à cette question

Harry Potter vs Twilight Question

Out of all the couples in Harry Potter and Twilight, which haut, retour au début 3 (or less) do toi think whose relationship would last in the real world (i.e. if they were merely humans/Muggles)

Harry Potter
1. Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger. I think a relationship that is built on friendship first can prove a good trait in finding a potential husband/wife. I know sometimes going out with a friend (especially a best friend) can ruin a friendship if they break up, but in Ron and Hermione's case, they've been Friends for so long, that even if they broke up, I think they would still be friends. They also treat each other equally and with respect. They're not just attracted to each other because of their looks.

2. Nymphadora Tonks and Remus Lupin. She loved him even though he was a monster and even though he thought he wasn't good enough for her and Teddy, he did stick around and stay in their marriage. If Lupin was a normal human, he wouldn't feel the need to walk out on the woman he loves. Even though there is an age gap, I think they can make it work.

3. Molly and Arthur Weasley. They already have 7 kids together and she obviously didn't marry him for his money. I think they're a good couple who l’amour each other and proved their relationship could stand decades.
----------------
Twilight
1. Sam Uley and Leah Clearwater. I think this is the only couple that could last in the real world. If neither of them had the werewolf/shapeshifter trait, then Sam would have never imprinted on Emily and Leah wouldn't have turned into a bitch. They were already high school sweethearts and he even had a nickname for her (Leelee). If they were average humans, I think they could have married and have kids if they wanted too. I don't know too much about the background of their relationship, but they seemed like a good couple to me.

I think the other relationships in Twilight were merely based on physical appearances and convenience. For instance, I don't think Bella and Edward's relationship would last if they were both humans and didn't have the conveniences of staying young, rich, and beautiful forever. Same goes for the other couples.
 Out of all the couples in Harry Potter and Twilight, which haut, retour au début 3 (or less) do toi think whose relationship would last in the real world (i.e. if they were merely humans/Muggles)
 Gred_and_Forge posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Harry Potter vs Twilight Réponses

cassie-1-2-3 said:
I believe that any two people can make a relationship work in the real world as long as they l’amour each other and want to make it last, regardless of circumstance.

So, all of the mutual romantic relationships.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
KateKicksAss said:
I agree about Tonks and Lupin. I wasn't a huge fan of that pairing, but I do think that based on that, and like toi said, Tonks loved him even though he was a monster and much older than her, and that he stuck around, I think that one would have worked out.
i also think that Ron and Hermione would have wordked out, agreed about the friendship.

Also, Bellatrix and Voldemort. Yeah, they weren't a couple, but if they were muggles, I think it would have, I mean, Bellatrix would have been happy to be bossed around and/or abused par him, and if he was still evil, he probably would have done that, but he'd also l’amour her, I'm a big Bellamort shipper, :P

I also think that Fleur and Bill would have worked, I mean, she clearly loved him for who he was, since she didn't desert him after he was disfigured par Greyback, and wanted to get married anyways.

As for Twilight, I agree about Sam and Leah, and everything toi a dit about them.

I also think Mike and Jessica, maybe, even though we don't know much about them, since they seemed to have plus in common than Mike and Bella, and they were a normal, High School couple, :P

I also think that Victoria and James would have worked out, since she clearly loved him, since she went to such elaborate attempts to avenge his death, and they were both "evil".
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
next question »