I liked Santana's solo in the one from "Journey", but I didn't like Puck's. It was not good. And this time, Mercedes' high note at the end was unnecesary. The first cover was way much better.

the other one has too much autotune. At the end, when Mercedes gives her high note, the choir sounds like Alvin and the chipmunks.

I love Santana's voice I just don't think it's suited for this sonh

I guess it's just because I'm used to this one

It's a hard choice. I loved the heart they had in the Pilot, but I also loved that everyone was in the Journey version. And the outfits. The clapping was annoying, though.

I like the journey one also but I have a special place for the Pilot version.

it was cute and natural <3

I liked the addition of Santana (obviously), but besides that it seemed too over the top to me. The original was more natural and to me it's the original.