répondre à cette question

Ghost whisperer Question

Does Melinda See Jim as JIM, orr Jim as SAM??

Ok. I have been wondering this as well, because a lot of people always says that "only Mel & the viewers see Jim as JIM", which is what I would have always preferred to be the truth, (that she still saw Jim as Jim & not as the Sam guy as well.

But if that's true, then where did we ever learn that?? Because in season 4 she says that she's sees the same guy Eli & Delia see, & that hes not Jim, but she knows that Jim is in him somewhere, & I don't remember her ever retracting from that comment.

Yet, everyone I always talk to says that Mel sees him as Jim as well as us @ home. Soo I just wanted to ask how we know that..??

Again, don't get me wrong! I really, REALLY wish that she saw Jim still as Jim.. & Ithink it would make sense through her gift to still see Jim as Jim because of seeing his spirit/the real him & what not.. I just, I don't think they unfortunatly wrote it that way. :( haha.

Thoughts..??
 CA_Girl posted il y a plus d’un an
next question »

Ghost whisperer Réponses

richieC509 said:
I'm so confused.. The writers did a major TV NO NO...Did toi notice that on Jim/Sam's name badge in the hospital the picture is of the Jim who Died???? Not the Sam who we used to see last season in the reflection ou mirror. Only Melinda and the TV viewers are supposed to see Jim as the old Jim who died lol...And how did Jim become a Dr in 5 years??? ou was Sam a Dr before he died? Jim/Sam's name on his hospital badge says S. James Lucas M.D." not Dr. S Lucas and not Dr. J Clancy. A lot of flubs here! and they are almost trying to make it seem as if last an never happened and that we the viewers all are to dumb to realize the corner the backed themselves into. It made good Drama last season but does not follow up this season..They should of used a "the whole death of Jim was a dream thingy" and had her wake up from it in the seasons premiere this an and start fresh...I'm not happy thus far
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
RIPGwenStacy said:
Melinda sees him as Sam. She says it to Eli when Sam is still in the hospital. She says "I see what toi guys see. Different eyes, hair face. But i see that look in his eyes."
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
ghostgrl said:
No, Aiden see's Sam and so does Melinda. During a visit to the hospital in season 4 Mel is talking outside of Sam's room looking at him through the large window and she says "I see the same man toi see, it's not Jim, but I know he's in there". She can feel Jim because of their connection and she's knows he jumped inside Sam's body. But, in season 5 episode 1 Mel brings Aiden to see Jim on the morning of his 5th birthday at the hospital where Jim's a resident. Aiden lifts Jim ID badge and looks at it closely and the camera even pans a bit so it can be seen better. The picture on the ID is 100% Jim, not Sam.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
M3tr0ch1ck said:
in Season 4 Ep 19 "Thrilled to Death", about 24mins 31secs into the episode, we see "Jim" running across the rue where he runs into Delia, who hesitates and stammers the name Jim upon his greeting. It can be safely assumed Delia hesitates because what she actually sees physically is "Sam" although she knows its actually Jim's spirit. To further support this hypothesis, a bit further in this scene an old EMT co-worker of Jim, Bobby Tierge, greets Delia warmly. When the Jim we physically see in the scene states Bobby's full name, he gives him a strange look because he doesn't know who this guy is {because he physically sees SAM, who is a stranger to him}. Delia quickly introduces "Jim" {who we see} as "Sam" {who everyone else sees. This is proven at 25min 09 sec into the episode when their reflections in a storefront montrer Delia standing suivant to the physical Sam who is being introduces to Bobby. After an awkward exchange Bobby runs off to answer an EMT call while Jim laments about how many shifts he and Bobby were on together, the number of people they've helped and the double dates he and Melinda took with Bobby and his various girlfriends. It is clear from this episode that although we, the viewers, see "Jim", everyone else sees "Sam" As a bonus, to begin to address the whole Sam/Jim Dr thing, at 58min 50sec into the episode "Jim" mentions he always wanted to be a doctor, and that apparently a an before he was struggling to find time to take all the medical prerequisites. Upon sending for his transcripts (as Sam), Jim realizes (Sam) already took all the math and science prereqs when he (Sam) was getting his Architecture degree. This means now "Jim" as the character Sam, can go to med school. convoluted? YES! I hope this helps. In a nutshell Melinda and everyone else physically sees Sam, but spiritually Melinda sees Jim.
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
throwawayacct said:
Everyone here sucks, i hope toi come back on here to see this, i literally made this throwaway acct in hopes toi see this commentaire and anyone else for that matter because this question bothered me too. Everyone skipped over the fact that melinda DOES admit ONLY she sees sam as jim in episode 12 of season 4, the episode is called “ This Joint’s Haunted “ and in the beginning mel asks jim if he remembers ever being sam and he says no and he also didnt remember being a ghost and joked to melinda “so youve been seeing this sam for two months” and melina laughed and told him ONLY SHE SEES SAM AS JIM quote “Only i see toi as you” and jim finishes saying “but everyone else” and then she jim looks sad and yeah end of story. Melinda sees sam as jim 😩
select as best answer
posted il y a plus d’un an 
next question »