I can't get used to calling her anything else.
I'll switch if I'm specifically referring to a personality (like if I was talking about her real personality and wanted people to know that I'd say Madeline) but just in general I still think of her as Mellie. Like if I was doing a pick asking something like 'favourite character' or 'prettiest character' I'd list her as Mellie.

I usually switch between Mellie and November. Or actually put Mellie/November. I've never called her Madeline.

Most of the time it's Mellie or November but I have never properly called her Madeline. It is mostly November in the same way as Caroline is Echo to me.

Usually Mellie, sometimes November. It's confusing. I'm just going to start calling her Melvembaline :)

I like the image for November, because she looks really spaced out and doll-like :)

Haha the one for November is actually Miracle Laurie at a convention haha =D

I always call her Mellie.

November and Mellie are two completely different characters to me, so depending on what's going on, is what I'll call her...like if Mellie's kissing Paul, I'll say Mellie, if November kicked ass I'll say November, say goes for the rest of the actives...except maybe Claire LOL but it'll happen sooner or later..LOL

Mellie, I am a little biased towards first impressions/first characters. So for me, even if I'm not digging her at a certain time, shes my fave. I'll also agree with DefineDelicate.