Barnabas was very effected when his beloved sister called him wicked and said she wouldn't come back until he learned how to be good again. It would have been great if she could have visited him again.

Sarah's return would have been great, but Maggie was one of my favorites. I liked the rest of these except for Amy and Adam. I thought they were both a royal pain in the a**.

As a child I really identified with Amy, and I hated it when she and Chris were written out so abruptly, but I think--storyline wise--Sarah's return would have made the most impact. An acknowledgment of how far Barnabas had come from those early "wicked" days.

Sarah would have effected Barnabas the most. Although I would've liked to see Maggie, or Chris come back. Sarah would have been a reminder of how much he had changed. I too didn't like when Chris just left cause I wanted to see if he ever got cured of the werewolf curse. I have to agree that Adam and Amy were a royal pain in the as*.

Maggie was very important to the story because she was the first woman Barnabas saw as Josette and I think she was very crucial.

I added Gerard because James Storm has said that he was to play a modern day version of the character once the plot switched back to 1971, but ABC canceled the show before that could happen. My personal choice for a return was still Sarah, though. Loved that little ghost.

Victoria. I liked the storyline when she was the main character. I grew attached to her and I really wanted to find out about her past. Her story intrigued me, and I'm a little sad now to find out how unpopular she is in the fandom. :-(

Sarah! Barnabas needed to see his baby sister again and to have her forgive him would have meant everything to him.